The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    oleeb's picture

    "The Preacher And The Slave"

    Above: the body of IWW organizer Joe Hill after his execution 94 years ago in 1915.

    I've been thinking a lot about how Americans today are being asked to "understand" that somewhere down the road they will get the healthcare system we should have had for the past 50 years and how the pathetic, half-assed pieces of legislation in Congress are "the best we could do" and that none of them will even begin to take effect for years, delaying what little good they will produce.  I've been thinking a lot about how the American people are being told that "we" are starting to see economic daylight but the "recovery" may well be "jobless" and that the growing army of 15 million unemployed Americans are supposed to be patient and "give it time" and "wait for conditions to improve" but not to expect the federal government to go out of it's way to create jobs or stimulate the economy further because "we" have to be "fiscally responsible" in these trying times... at least when it comes to doing anything for the common American. 

    Of course when they say "we", they really mean "we the wealthy, powerful and priveleged who caused every single one of the major and quite preventable problems we face today" will provide for our own needs, the expense of which you little people will have to pay for.  "We" certainly cannot ask the wealthy to pay more because that would stifle economic growth don't ya know.  

    The common people are asked by the President they elected last year to keep in mind that it is important the country not spend irresponsibly on things it doesn't need: like jobs for them and their family members.  Yet the sky has been and remains the limit for the crooked financier class of Wall Street thieves the new President favors.  

    And despite spending more on "defense" than all the other nations on earth (friend and foe combined), we have an endless pot of money for more wars and the weapons of war no matter how pointless, futile or reckless.  There isn't even a discussion or mention of a possible discussion of cutting the grotesquely bloated, malignant, job killing, military budget in light of the nation's impending bankruptcy and massive unemployment problem!  "We" won't allow that to be discussed because "we" are terrified of a band of determined criminals holed up in the mountains of Pakistan who scare "us" to death and provide "us" with a permanent excuse to continue this wasteful spending ad infinitum. 

    And I have been thinking a great deal about Obama's Orwellian deception regarding escalating the war in Afghanistan in order "to begin" withdrawing troops in 18 months "depending upon conditions on the ground" vs the clear statements by his own Secretaries of Defense and State that there is no firm committment to withdrawal at all

    And I've been thinking about how, as the mulitple crises facing our nation become deeper and deeper, the common people are increasingly told to trust their corrupt and complacent political leaders who feed them these lines of bullshit all of which amount to telling the people that the priorities of the wealthy and powerful are what needs tending to and that the plight of average Dick and Jane, no matter how severe, is always what comes last (except for a brief few weeks near election time).  And I've been thinking how all their lame excuses for why the needs of the people can never be addressed amount to "pie in the sky", and then this song of Joe Hill's came to my mind.  Seems to me we need a great deal more of the spirit demonstrated by those who sung this and other Wobbly songs in times past.  Unless and until we recapture that spirit and act upon it we will be doing little more than lining up for our pie in the sky. 

    It is sung to the tune of the old Christian hymn "In The Sweet By and By".

    The Preacher And The Slave

    by: Joe Hill

    Long-haired preachers come out every night,
    Try to tell you what's wrong and what's right;
    But when asked how 'bout something to eat
    They will answer with voices so sweet:

    CHORUS:
    You will eat, bye and bye,
    In that glorious land above the sky;
    Work and pray, live on hay,
    You'll get pie in the sky when you die. (That's a lie!)

    The starvation army they play,
    They sing and they clap and they pray
    'Till they get all your coin on the drum
    Then they'll tell you when you're on the bum:

    Holy Rollers and jumpers come out,
    They holler, they jump and they shout.
    Give your money to Jesus they say,
    He will cure all diseases today.

    CHORUS
    If you fight hard for children and wife --
    Try to get something good in this life --
    You're a sinner and bad man, they tell,
    When you die you will sure go to hell.

    CHORUS

    Workingmen of all countries, unite,
    Side by side we for freedom will fight;
    When the world and its wealth we have gained
    To the grafters we'll sing this refrain:

    FINAL CHORUS:
    You will eat, bye and bye,
    When you've learned how to cook and to fry.
    Chop some wood, 'twill do you good,
    And you'll eat in the sweet bye and bye.

    Comments

    My apologies for the spacing weirdness above with respect to the lyrics. I don't know why that is happening and don't know how to fix it. But the spacing issue doesn't change the meaning so sorry for the technical difficulty.


    Oleeb, this is a soul searching post. I hereby award you the Dayly Blog of the Day Award for this here TPMCafe Site, given to all of you from all of me.

    You have really got me to tears on this one.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k34COolbdmY


    Blech!!!!


    Thanks DD.

    That is the actual voice of Florence Reese singing Which Side Are You On at the beginning of the youtube link in your comment. Extraordinary lady indeed. I saw her sing her famous song at the base of the Washington monument, accompanied by no less than Pete Seeger in September, 1981. It was a remarkable little performance by the songwriter and the great old fella on banjo.


    Lousgirl84: I am not familiar with the term "Blech" but I infer that it is derogatory. If so, then may I politely suggest that you listen and learn from your more experienced elders -- assuming that '84 is the year of your birth? But whether it is, or it isn't, learn to identify, when you see one, a soul-searching, poignant, historically-referenced and intelligently-interpreted blog, like this one.


    Thanks, Oleeb; this bears a second and third reading, after the tears recede. What a strange track we are on right now in this country. Here is Baez:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_f2J4ceCikI

    "I never died, said he." Well, then.


    You do realize of all the denizens of the 100 acre woods, the one who did far less and was most feckless was poor always depressing Eeyore.


    Wendy, how did you do it? I have to take a lesson. You conveyed my thoughts perfectly, respectfully, but with a pizzaz I have never equaled. BRAVA!


    Oleeb -- excellent, and thought-provoking. Is there a reason you didn't break it into paragraphs? I am worried that some will give up without reading this because it is ponderous without para breaks.

    This is great writing. Thank you. It is a keeper!


    How nice, Cville! I was just coming back to commend wendy for the most polite smack-down of willfully ignorant pseudo-criticism ever!
    I'm pretty sure I DO know what "Blech!" means.
    But I think she deserved it even if Oleeb weren't her Elder. ;-}


    Good suggestions. It was almost stream of consciousness when being written. I'll see about breaking it up.


    See that you did it! I love this blog! I hope it gets the attention it deserves.


    “Don’t mourn for me. Organize!” - Joe Hill


    You go, girl! The Dem-o-cratic par-tay can't even get EFCA passed. Lord love a duck.
    Ooops- I forgot: they are no longer the Party of Labor. Crap.


    Great stream Oleeb~~~~~! All the incoherent political decisions roll around in empty stomachs these days.

    I have cynic rising. Non-threatening opinions of hungry people are considered irrelevant to the "grafters" in DC. Their Chinese credit cards for war aren’t quite maxed-out. Pie in the face would do them some good. But who can afford pie?




    Many thanks. In my haste I just wrote in one big block, but you were right about breaking it up.


    Why, thank you, READY, but I'm trying to learn to tone it down.


    Jeeeeeeeeeez you are good.


    Well said, Oleeb.


    What a great post oleeb.

    I've been almost despondent these last few days as Obama convened his "jobs summit." Simultaneously, we learned that Harley Davidson workers in PA had to accept extreme concessions to keep their jobs from moving to KY. And this on the heels of Mercury Marine workers in WI having to accept major contract concessions to keep their jobs from moving to OK.

    Anecdotally, I know many friends who have lost their jobs over the last two decades. I cannot think of any one of them who found for themselves a replacement job that was actually an improvement on the former. Instead, the case wherein one went to work at a Wal-Mart store in exchange for his career as a union pressman at a printing plant remains the norm.

    There is simply no consideration in Obama's jobs discussions for what kind of jobs the working class has available to them, and for good reason. "We" have long since determined that family supporting jobs are too inconvenient for the capitalists. Instead, "we" must teach the workers to become "more efficient" - not so the workers can enjoy greater wealth or better benefits and thus share in the benefit of greater efficiencies - but so "we" can bludgeon them with increased competition for "our" jobs and thus gain even greater concessions from "our" workers.

    As you point out so succinctly, the workers are no longer considered part of the "WE" that Obama and Behrnanke and Paulson, et. al., talk about. It is truly disgusting, and it is time for the worker's to commence standing up for themselves and demanding the worker's portion of the capitalist pie. God knows, "We" aren't about to part with any of it, and "We" presently hold all the cards.

    Thanks for this posting, oleeb. Not sure from whence he'll come, but we need a few more Joe Hills today as much as at any other time in our history.


    And don't even get me started on the GOP meme that we must pass tax cuts for small businesses because that is where all the new jobs are being created.

    I fear they might be right about the creation of new jobs. But just how many of those jobs are family supporting? Probably not many, especially given the GOP's concern that HCR is too much for small businesses to absorb. It seems providing health care benefits for workers is simply too extreme a cost for these job providers to shoulder.

    And is it not the case that small business is where the jobs are at only because we have transferred almost all manufacturing jobs to other countries?

    Don't get me wrong. I appreciate small business entrepreneurs. But I never felt comfortable trying to build a sustainable economy on a series of bed and breakfasts or a whole network of craft shops selling the latest in homemade fashion wear. I most certainly don't expect these entrepreneurs to provide jobs that can sustain a family, and I fear instead that the GOP and "WE" would argue that such wage and benefit levels are simply unreasonable to expect in today's economy. (Meaning, "WE" win and you lose! Get used to it, sucker!)

    It's far better to fight back, and it will take some real creative leadership to arrive at a plan - and a movement - that can knock "We" on "OUR" asses.


    We keep hearing from the punditocracy that Down-sized Workers need to be re-educated for Tech jobs. Huh? Wasn't that what the Clinton Administration said when they got NAFTA passed? It's some magical thinking that people who always do the practical work in this country, or used to do the manufacturing jobs, would be better off sitting at computers. They forget how much of the tech work got outsourced to India and the Phillipines, and how sending the manufacturing jobs off-shore will screw the country long-term. It's so popular to blame it on "Federal regulations (environmental), Union demands, and tax-policy-that-kills-business." How many American companies like Rubbermaid, did Walmart kill, trying to sqeeze every penny-per-unit out of them until they could no longer compete with a Chinese version?
    Remember when some business models were based on the idea that if you paid your workers well, they could actually BUY the products they made? And when there were ads on the teevee of huge groups of Union Workers advocating in song:

    "Look for the Union label..."?


    The biggest problem with all of that is that small business cannot, under any circumsances, create the literally millions of jobs that we need to get our people back to work within any reasonable time frame. It would take decades for small business to produce that number of jobs at any income level, let alone at a level that pays living wages.

    Other than big business, which obviously could not care less about the welfare of it's own employees let alone the American worker generally speaking, only the federal government has the resources to put large numbers of people to work quickly enough in productive activity to make a real difference. The conservadems, unfortunately led by our President, reject government work programs, not because they don't work because they do, on ideological grounds. That is the only way out of this economic depression and it is, indeed, a depression. If Obama stays on his present conservadem course he's going to look a whole lot more like Hoover than any Democratic President since Hoover. We are hearing from him the same nostrums that the Hoover administration ladled out to the public between 1929 and 1933 and all we have to do is recall how badly out of touch and off the mark Hoover and his response to the economic collapse was.

    Now, in the aftermath of the first economic collapse since the 30's our officials remain in the same sort of denial the stalwart free enterprisers of the 30's were in as they are stymied by the situation and not having any adequate response they counsel the nation to allow the all benificent marketplace to magically regenarate the 8 million jobs lost in the past year. The surreal scenes depicted on our tv's of our highest government officials discussing a "jobless recovery" demonstrates just how out of touch they are with reality and the circumstances of our people. The vast numbers of unemployed are merely and intellectual construct for the chumps in the White House and in Congress. It is not a reality they recognize, acknowledge or feel any urgency doing anything about. Their emergency was last year. Their chief client, Wall Street's criminals, was saved from anything like the pain they should have suffered as a result of the criminal fraud, ponzi schemes, and irresponsibile greed thus they tell us that had they not given them nearly a trillion dollars in free, freshly minted money from our treasury it would all have been worse and it was the only way that it could have been done. This is, of course, a pathetic lie that is being allowed to stand by our media and even much of left blogistan because it is such a mind boggling situation. But the truth is one needn't understand all the details to know that giving a bunch of unethical crooks free money is a bad idea. At minimum, every dime given away should have been given only on condition that it be repaid with substantial interest and that the industry do nothing to oppose the regulation required to prevent the greed addicts from falling off the wagon again and destroying the world economy a second time.

    History will not be at all kind to the capitalists, but likewise it will not be kind at all to Obama or his henchmen (particularly Geithner and Summers) or the Congressional Democrats all of whom failed to protect the interests of the nation or it's people going forward.


    Remember Wendy that Leona Helmsley expressed about taxes, what the punditocracy and their patrons really believe which is that like taxes, the rules are for the little people and they can be changed at any time by our betters to make sure it is the little people who always must adapt in order to preserve our obscene wealth and privelege. God forbid the rules should be applied to the rich and powerful. They might have to do something other than grow fatter and greedier and lazier.


    I got to thinking also about campaign promises; I remember that Obama spoke about the need to re-draft some of our international trade agreements. As soon as some folks yelled "Protectionism!!!!" he backed off, yes?
    I'm just listening to (god save me) Hardball while I'm doing chores. Tweety and Chuck Todd are agreeing about Obama's trip to Allentown, PA, being god, so that O can show how he does empathize, like the sainted Bill Clinton (of de-regulatory and NAFTA fame) "feel the pain of the worker." Again, they point to the Perception of Obama; not the reality of the policies put forward by "Pointy-headed intellectuals."
    I'm a regular person, and I don't care much about selling empathy; I care about the health of the middle and lower classes. Where do the folks at the top think this will end? Apparently there have been a number of conceal gun permits issued to Goldman Sachs employees. WTF?
    And I had forgotten totally about Leona Helmsley!


    The Joe Hill reference is right on and its implications may turn to something scary for this government. I heard an African-American member of Congress talking about unemployment in minority communities. He said in all seriousness that the time was close at hand when unemployed might march on Washington. Cobra is running out for thousands. Unemployment checks also. No small dip in the jobless rates is going to turn this thing around. Working people are in too much trouble already. Where are those high-paying green jobs? How is that a government is so stupid as to not spend money to build infra-structure, to immediately put working people into a job. College grads are not finding work and leaving school with $25,000 in debt. There is a tipping point here at which the social fabric dissolves for so many people that anything can happen.

    I wonder if anyone up in that White House, all those government people with a job and health insurance--which they keep when they leave office--are thinking on what might be coming down the street.

    If you're nervous about the Right acting up, you'd better start thinking about acting up on your own. The Left is mighty tough on the blogs these days. The Right Wing is hitting the streets.

    Joe Hill, a blogger? I think not.


    You're aboslutely right. I look forward to the left hitting the streets and pray for it daily. That's what woke up the government in the 30's and it's what it will take today.


    Thanks, Wendy - haven't thought about that tune in ages.

    http://unionsong.com/u103.html


    Thanks for the advice, and I think you're right; the funny bone is the best one to beat someone over the head with (hahahaha!). You and I have sparred from time to time, but I've also learned from you. I am glad that I am still capable of that, and I appreciate your feedback.