Barth's picture

    That Anniversary Again

    No time for something new.  This was written in 2009 and will have to do for today's sad anniversary:

     

     

     

    It means only one thing to those of us of a certain age. It was the day of days, the event of our national lives. That it no longer is the focus of every succeeding November 22 tells us that one day even September 11 will pass without substantial notice. Yet whether cable television devotes every moment to reliving a national nightmare, its importance remains the same and, as Mad Men showed so well a few weeks back, any recollection of that day can trigger many floods, even among those who, unlike some of us, were very, very young that day.

     

    Yes, I was called up short when Mad men's creator, Matt Weiner, mentioned that not everyone knows that Oswald was murdered only a few days after the President was killed, since there is no American who was over five years old at the time who doesn't remember that and the sense, at that very minute, that we had spun completely out of control exactly as Mad Men reminded us.

     

    And, yes, Mad Men was also right in the sense that the world just ended that day and began again, with different values, different history, and different rules. The guilt and sadness over the death of our young President resulted, it is true, in the seminal legislation of our time, the Civil and Voting Rights Acts of 1964 and 1965, respectively, and medicaid and medicare also in 1965. But the spirit of the era was gone and gone, it seemed, forever.

     

    Ask not what your country can do for you: ask what you can do for your country.

     

     

    That sense of obligation to our fellow citizens, the articulation of the underpinning of Roosevelt's New Deal but now in the hands of

     

    a new generation of Americans -- born in this century, tempered by war, disciplined by a hard and bitter peace, proud of our ancient heritage, and unwilling to witness or permit the slow undoing of those human rights to which this nation has always been committed, and to which we are committed today at home and around the world

     

     

    President Kennedy's death marked the end of an era, not the beginning he had promised us and his hopeful ideals for the country were replaced, first, by the war in Vietnam, followed by the war on the Great Society and then of the New Deal itself. The election of President Obama is the first thing that has happened since then which provides even a hint that we can get back on the path President Kennedy set for us.

     

    But as much as Matt Weiner offered a reminder of how many people have no recollection of November 22, 1963, a diary on Daily Kos the other day shows that the path to darkness remains before us as well. We live in a time when a person with a Jewish sounding last name who blogs about the limits of Sarah Palin's appeal receives an email about "Why People Like to Stuff People Like You into Ovens." This is the combustible atmosphere that existed in 1963. Deny that at your own peril.

     

    The diarist advised that we not fear the people who are out there---the "crazies" as Regina Spektor calls them---and that advice is worth trying to heed, but it will not be easy.

     

    Over and over the reminders take over this space.

     

    We are living in a time when a doctor providing abortions is murdered and people cheer or try to justify it.

     

    We are living in a time when elected officials can appear on Meet the Press and justify threats of violence and even the overthrow of our government and are not hooted into an apology or oblivion.

     

    We live in a time when a man proudly brags about the gun he brought to a rally where the President of the United States was speaking and yet this incident gets less coverage than whether some guy tried to hoodwink cable tv (big woop) by claiming his boy was in a balloon.

     

    We live in a time when people are "praying" for the President of the United States hoping for his death.

     

    We live among hate.

     

    Hate cost us a president and almost two generations of progress. It is countenanced today by people who should know better and there appear to be nobody or very few in the Republican Party willing to speak out against it, the way the otherwise racist William F. Buckley did against the John Birch Society

    or even Sen Prescott Bush spoke out against, tepidly, the "methods" used by Senator Joseph McCarthy in his anti-Communist crusades.

     

    Part of this day, as every November 22 since 1963, will be spent mourning our late President, but the day should also be dedicated to never allowing this hatred to change our world again.

     

    Comments

    Hate cost us a president and almost two generations of progress

    As a counterpoint view to the "two generations of progress" part, I recommend Frank Rich's article for the Nov. 28 issue of New York Magazine,

    What Killed JFK
    The hate that ended his presidency is eerily familiar.

    wherein the anniversary can be discussed in comparison with current events and what we now know about past events, without hagiography of JFK (or Obama for that matter.)

    P.S. I was alive and witnessed the aftermath. I didn't see the "killing of two generations of progress," I saw a country coalesce in shock (where there had been disagreement before) for a short time around the successor and the government, and then in short order, this sort of youthquake started up in opposition to their elders....


    I was there with you, AA, working my first job out of college and glued to the television set from the night after the murder through the shooting of Oswald to the funeral caissons rolling down Pennsylvania Avenue. 

    And I did not witness the "killing of two generations of progress."

    The Jack Kennedy I remember was a divisive figure. He was young, inexperienced, and his brief tenure was studded by many gaffes and a few tense, brilliant moments. He frightened many traditional Americans. He was not yet a President fully in charge of his powers and his administration. 

    No one knows whether he would have sent more troops to fight in Vietnam. No one knows whether he would have been able to steer civil rights legislation through Congress. No one knows whether 

    But "only the good die young" is a meme that has been kind to him.

    I was a fan of Jack Kennedy. But he was not a mythical figure. Smart, courageous, fascinated by governance, and getting better at it. Then he was gone.

    And hate? it was not a culture of hate that killed Kennedy. it was a sociopath with a rifle against a background of political conflict not unlike any time in the history of the world. 

    LBJ was hated more, and not assassinated. Dick Nixon was hated more, and not assassinated. Ronald Reagan was loved, and seriously wounded. Bill Clinton was hated with an almost unimaginable venom, and not killed. 

    I don't see the predictive connection between hate and assassination.


    The two generations to which I was referring were the ones that followed his death.  It can scarcely be questioned that those forty years were a march toward selfishness and a rebirth of the gilded age, after thirty years going in quite the opposite direction.

    The Kennedy debunkers ignore how much he inspired so many of us who "learned the language" during his presidency.  I have spent a lifetime in public service based largely on his call, and I am not even remotely alone in that.

    What he meant in fulfilling his campaign promise to get this country moving again, tempered by his warning in his famous inaugural about how we will not be finished even during our time on this earth, should (and does) have meaning today.

    Let us begin.

     

     

     


    Oh Jeez, Mathews almost had me weeping.

    Now I'm done!

     


    Latest Comments