The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    oleeb's picture

    Oscar Opinions Anyone?

    Departing just for a moment from politics, what do you think about this year's nominees and their chances on Oscar night?

    In my opinion, this really was one of the best years for films in a very long time.  The only film I saw that didn't get the kind of recognition I thought it deserved for the Oscars was Gran Torino which is a film I consider a sort of masterpiece by Eastwood.  What an amazing piece of work that was!  Despite my disappointment over Gran Torino not being nominated for anything, I'm actually going to watch the Academy Awards program tonight with interest for the first time in a long time because there were so many excellent films and so many truly remarkable performances given.  Anyone care to venture their opinions and/or predictions on the main awards anyway?  I don't have any special knowledge or skill in this area so I don't pretend to know more or better than anyone else, but I'm an avid filmgoer like, I'm sure, many of you are.  Here are my guesses and thoughts:

     

    BEST PICTURE:

    Slumdog Millionaire

    Despite the very strong field, I'd have to say Slumdog is the most unique and outstanding of them in a year of genuinely masterful movies.  Slumdog overall was so different, so gripping and took the audience on such a wildly unpredictable and unexpected ride that it stands out.  Having said that, I wouldn't be at all surprised to see any of the nominated films win.  IMHO, each is worthy of the award in different ways.  Excellent group of films indeed!

    BEST DIRECTOR

    David Fincher, Curious Case of Benjamin Button

    Boyle is likely to win for Slumdog but after agonizing over it and that's just fine by me because he did a great job, but personally I come down on the side of Fincher, Benjamin Button's Director, as having done the most outstanding job of directing.  It was a difficult story to convey and lengthy too.  If the direction were not as superb as it was, the picture would not have worked.  Again, all nominated seem deserving to me, but this is my preference.

    BEST ACTOR

    Sean Penn

    This is another close call but I come down with Penn because the role is so different in that Penn had to convey this man who was very "out of the ordinary" in so many different ways without being cartoonish or slipping into caricature.  Penn's portrayal was not only believable, he became the character in every way and captured that elusive character and spirit of a person that separates a good performance from something extraordinary.  The portrayal of Harvey Milk was honest, sympathetic  and real.  Penn, it seems to me, may well be the best actor of his generation.  I don't feel this is a slam dunk at all though and there's no potential result would be terribly surprising given the high quality of each performance.

    BEST ACTRESS

    Kate Winslet

    Definitely one of the toughest categories to choose from in a year when there are many such categories.  I go with Kate Winslet because it was just a tour de force on her part.  She is an incredibly gifted performer.  Meryl Streep whose ability is just amazing showed again that there seems no limit to her depth and skill in conveying a character and all the compicated facets of a a human being.  But, by a hair, I say Winslet.

    BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR

    Phillip Seymour Hoffman

    I know Heath Ledger will probably win for what was, admittedly, an outstanding performnce, but I personally come down for Hoffman whose subtle perforance was powerful, intense, masterful, and demonstrated his amazing range of ability in a very difficult role.

    BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS

    Marisa Tomei

    I have to say that all the actresses in this category deserve this award.  It was hard for me to choose especially between Tomei, Taraji Henson, and Amy Adams all of whom are more than deserving of this award.  Adams was astounding and I really thought that Henson was the brightest light among many in Benjamin Button.  In The Wrester, when Tomei was "performing" for the last time, the expressions on her face which amounted to an unspoken conversation about her character's life that took place on the screen did it for me.  It was just a devastating and moving performance.  Another categoy I'd be happy to see any of the nominees win, but I just come donw for Tomei in the end.

    So that's my take on the biggest categories.  Anyone else care to share their assessments?  Add to the catgories if you wish.  Enjoy!

     

     

     

     

    Comments

    My predictions:

    1) The show will go long.

    2) Some of the fashions will generate headlines.

    3) A speech or two will go off the rails.

    4) The musical numbers will be incredibly boring.

    5) I'll watch all the way to the end anyway.


    Living in the little, rural desert town I call home has translated to my having seen less than half of the nominees this year oleeb, so hazarding a guess is presumptive on my part. That said, I´ve been invited to a Oscar party here in another sleepy little desert town this evening. It should be fun regardless of my lack of knowledge of this year's subject films. As you said, Ledger was excellent, but I too find Hoffman's performance(s) brilliant on so many levels, I would have to cast my personal vote for him.


    Re: #4 - Especially because Springsteen wuz robbed!!


    I certainly agree on Springsteen!


    I don't want Winslet to win because her acceptance speech wiil last longer than her movie.

    I haven't been a real Streep fan, but I was in the 8th grade at a Catholic school in 1964 (like the kids in Doubt) and she totally inhabits the nuns of that era including my dearly departed aunt.


    My picks:

    Best picture: Slumdog Millionaire (will win & should win)

    Best Actor: Mickey Rourke - The Wrestler (Although Sean Pennn was amazing too. I just can't picture anyone else as Randy the Ram)

    Best Director: Danny Boyle Slumdog Millionaire

    Best Supporting Actor: Closest call for me, but I'd give it to Heath Ledger. Yes, Phillip Seymour Hoffman was as good in Doubt, but he wasn't even the best performance in the film. Heath carried The Dark Knight (and it's his last role). For what it's worth I was rooting for Heath Ledger for Brokeback Mountain when he lost to Hoffman for Capote and it was a toss-up for me then as well.

    Best Actress: Meryl Streep embodying Sister Bernadine Mary, my high school principal.

    Best Supporting Actress: Viola Davis. I know she likely won't win because she was only in one scene and she'll split some votes with Amy Adams, but her performance was riveting. If not her, then Penelope Cruz for Vicky Cristina Barcelona.


    My cat Smokey's picks. She's totally anti- Slumdog Millioniare:

    Best Picture: Milk (obviously)
    Best Actor: Sean Penn for Milk
    Best Actress: Kate Winslet for the Reader (Smokey loves curling up with a book)
    Best Supporting Actor: Josh Brolin (Milk)
    Best Supporting Actress: Taraji P. Henson Curious Case of Benjamin Buttons (curiosity took at least one of Smokey's lives already).


    The cats in the farmyard concur.

    =D


    1. Not one of these films have I seen. The last genuine movin' picture show I attended in a genuine movin' picture thea-ate-er was X-Men 2. Yes, it is terribly sad.

    2. I didn't get invited to any Oscar parties they are wont to have in the middle of nowhere where I live. They usually involve bringing a hot dish to pass and quite frankly, by this time of year I am tired of sauerkraut and polish sausage in a crockpot.

    3. Unless the Oscar show is on CBS, I can't see it anyway. Since everything went digital, that's all we get.

    4. Is Springsteen gonna be on the Oscar show? I'd hate to miss that.

    5. My picks are the same as dijamo's cat. Cats don't lie.


    Best Picture: Slumdog Millionaire

    Best Actor: Richard Jenkins (my pick, but he probably won't win)

    Best Actress: Kate Winslet is going to win, but I thought Angelina Jolie was amazing.

    Best Supporting Actress: Viola Davis should win. Amy Adams was a close second. The others were mediocre at best.

    Best Supporting Actor: Heath Ledger will win. Philip Seymour Hoffman probably deserves to.

    I've actually been writing about this at Dagblog.com all week. And I'll be live blogging tonight, if anyone cares to stop by.

    Live Blog:

    www.dagblog.com

    My two cents on the nominees:

    http://dagblog.com/blogs/orlando


    Kewl, Thanks, Orlando!



    I'll have to check it out. Thanks!


    Orlando is keeping me in stiches over at DAG

    http://dagblog.com/live-blogs/live-blogging-academy-awards-510

    Highly rec'd


    As a fellow avid filmgoer I (belatedly) enjoyed your comments, oleeb. Looks as though you nailed Best Pic and Best Actor and Actress. I agree that it was an excellent year in terms of quality movies and outstanding performances.

    Slumdog Millionaire seems to fit well with the zeitgeist of the moment. Obama and its lead character, both blessed with unusual degrees of moxie, share a wildly improbable and meteoric rise from humble circumstances to the pinnacle of fame.

    Prior to the Academy Awards show I finally got around to seeing the 2003 movie Mystic River and thought it was fabulous. It was nominated for Best Picture for that year. What makes me mention it here is your mention of Penn--he won Best Performing Actor for his role in that movie. And Tim Robbins won Best Supporting Actor. I also thought Laura Linney (chillingly so) and Marcia Gay Harden were excellent in supporting roles, as the wives of these two characters. Harden was nominated but did not win. Penn also won for his role in Dead Man Walking so this is now three for him. I agree--he is a magnificent actor and possibly the best of this era.

    Meryl Streep was exceptional in Doubt, I agree. I was disappointed that Doubt did not receive more nominations. I thought it was an excellent movie which should appeal to many of our fellow tpmcafe denizens who appreciate nuance and complexity in human affairs. Phillip Seymour Hoffman was exceptional in it as well, I thought. He, too, is an enormously talented actor.

    Meryl Streep is the best actress I have seen over the past 30 years or so, among many enormously talented peers. Kate Winslet is most impressive as well, though.

    I have not seen the movie in which Penelope Cruz's performance won her Best Supporting Actress. One or two friends who saw it said they did not find her performance all that stellar.


    My mistake--Sean Penn was nominated for, but did not win, Best Actor Award in 1995 for his performance in Dead Man Walking.

    Hard for me to believe that movie came out 14 years ago now.