Outlets like the New York Times, NPR, and NBC have all reported on a drastic spike in antisemitic incidents, using data from the Anti-Defamation League. But where, exactly, does that data come from? I analyzed, finding a lot of confusion and conflation. https://t.co/yLtZoAwuAw
three cheers for Mari (assistant editor at Jewish Currents) doing the "fear fear itself" thing. She will no doubt get a lot of flack from those invested in stoking victimhood Olympics, when all she's trying to do is figure out the reality of the situation and what people should actually be fearing and what they should not:
Not to say that antisemitic incidents, especially violent ones, aren't concerning and upsetting. But actual spikes in hate crimes are notoriously difficult to measure, and before causing fear and creating new policy priorities, we need to know what's going on
The ADL didn't respond to my many questions about their numbers. But they're using multiple numbers for reported incidents in different posts, and a beating is lumped into the same count as a protest sign that says "Zionism is racism"
Furthermore, more attention on a certain type of incident generally leads to increased reporting of those incidents—and a change in how people categorize and think of as certain incidents.
A friend in Sales once advised me, "when you go to talk to people, always find out what they're measured on" - a useful piece of advice in evaluating many endeavours, & 1 it seems Mari is partially doing - the ADL is likely not measured on "accurately assessing the situation" - it's say getting more attention for the org & making ADL seem needed. Calming things down is likely not its goal, however desirable it might seem.
It was really tough finding it on the website, though! Other news has pushed it aside. I didn't see it on the home page and I didn't even see it on the World page.
I had to go to the "Middle East" sub section of the "World" section and scroll way down to find it published online back on May 26
Comments
three cheers for Mari (assistant editor at Jewish Currents) doing the "fear fear itself" thing. She will no doubt get a lot of flack from those invested in stoking victimhood Olympics, when all she's trying to do is figure out the reality of the situation and what people should actually be fearing and what they should not:
by artappraiser on Thu, 05/27/2021 - 3:26pm
A friend in Sales once advised me, "when you go to talk to people, always find out what they're measured on" - a useful piece of advice in evaluating many endeavours, & 1 it seems Mari is partially doing - the ADL is likely not measured on "accurately assessing the situation" - it's say getting more attention for the org & making ADL seem needed. Calming things down is likely not its goal, however desirable it might seem.
by PeraclesPlease on Thu, 05/27/2021 - 4:02pm
Not going with Mari Cohen's approach, not even going with NYTimes' approach:
Foxman served as the National Director of the Anti-Defamation League from 1987 to 2015, and is currently the League's National Director Emeritus
Is ironic because many pro-Palestian peeps have long thought of the NYTimes as an arm of the Israeli propaganda machine...
by artappraiser on Fri, 05/28/2021 - 12:56pm
apparently the offending front page looks like this:
It was really tough finding it on the website, though! Other news has pushed it aside. I didn't see it on the home page and I didn't even see it on the World page.
I had to go to the "Middle East" sub section of the "World" section and scroll way down to find it published online back on May 26
https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/05/26/world/middleeast/gaza-israel-children.html
by artappraiser on Fri, 05/28/2021 - 1:13pm