MURDER, POLITICS, AND THE END OF THE JAZZ AGE
by Michael Wolraich
Order today at Barnes & Noble / Amazon / Books-A-Million / Bookshop
MURDER, POLITICS, AND THE END OF THE JAZZ AGE by Michael Wolraich Order today at Barnes & Noble / Amazon / Books-A-Million / Bookshop |
There was the passing of Hitchens and Jobs and The Supreme Leader. And also Vaclav Havel. I went to the front pages of Huffington Post and The Daily Beast, and except for one opinion piece at the Huff, you wouldn't know that he had passed away.
The opinion piece by Lucas Kavner began:
This past week the world mourned the loss of both Vaclav Havel and Christopher Hitchens, two major thinkers who incidentally had a lot in common. Both moved mountains with their words and built philosophies around their larger-than-life personas. Both unexpectedly supported the Iraq War, defying their supposed leftist ideologies, and constantly questioned religion. Both were consistently tough to predict or pigeon-hole.
This is not to say I completely agree with Kavner. But Havel was an important person in the world of politics and activism, along with his contributions to the art world. He is a fascinating man who had some important things to say, and was able to say them in a powerful way.
One of my favorite quotes of his was:
Hope is a state of mind, not of the world. Hope, in this deep and powerful sense, is not the same as joy that things are going well, or willingness to invest in enterprises that are obviously heading for success, but rather an ability to work for something because it is good.
I hope to write a more in-depth blog about Havel in the near future. He was definitely more than someone who could toss out a good quote. He did have a profound influence on me over the years, having discovered him when I was 16 years old through my stumbling upon the writings of Milan Kundera.
I also think he, through his days as a politician in Czech government, demonstrates the modified adage: "if you're not part of the problem, you're not part of the solution."
Rest in Peace Vaclav. And thanks.
Comments
Havel was vastly more important than Hitchens. Only a serious set of blinkers puts Hitchens in Havel's league. In fact, Havel easily outstripped Hitchens both as a writer and as a public figure. Obviously, Havel is already in the history books. Hitchens, at best, goes in the occasional history dissertation with lots of footnotes. That's no disrespect to Hitchens. Few of us achieve the status of lively historical footnote. But it's disrespectful to both men's achievements to compare them.
Havel really was a great playwright. It's a shame that small countries have only one or two of their writers, at best, become the international representatives of "Czech literature," but if only one Czech playwright was going to be known outside Bohemia, Havel was a great pick.
I was driving home last night listening to Good King Wenceslaus on the radio, and thinking about Havel. Vaclav, of course, is the name that gets Latinized as "Wenceslaus," so King Wenceslaus is, I think, Vaclav IV. Vaclav Havel didn't want to be a king, but he was a great leader, and he never pretended to be a saint, but he did a lot of good for the world around him.
by Doctor Cleveland on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 12:11pm
I agree with you about the comparison with Hitchens.
The reason I brought up Huff and the Beast is that these sites portray themselves to have a focus on the political (and the arts), and yet someone as historical to the world of politics (and the arts) like Havel passing away can be reduced to a few opinion pieces for which one has to search in order to find it is sad. If anything his passing does allow the opportunity for news driven sites like these to expose people to the like of Havel that would otherwise not be exposed in the torrent of information we have these days. Who knows if many of the people working at these sites even know who he is.
by Elusive Trope on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 12:29pm
Oh, no need to apologize. You're right to point out how strange the coverage has been. It's like "We've lost two great leaders this week: the unforgettable and inspiring captain of our local bowling league, and also the Senator." Embarrassing for those alleged journalists.
by Doctor Cleveland on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 1:17pm
The Senator never could pick up the spare - but his lobbyists did pick up the checks.
by Donal on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 1:26pm
And here I though Kim Jong was just ill!
Hitch should not be put in the same league as Havel; although the brit did visit all the battlefields in Europe anyway.
Hitch was a stand up comic of the intelligentsia. He had a great vocabulary, a great sense of history and could respond (under the influence) better than any entertainer I have ever seen. As I said somewhere else, he was great when he took my side of things! But many times it was clear that he was present to debate for money and in order to sell his books/newspaper columns.
Havel saw it all. Hitch was my age and I assume saw only a portion of the devastation experienced in Britain as well as Europe.
My God Havel incorporated the full pain of a world wide depression as well as the Nazis and the commies.
I still marvel at how well Europe succeeded in building an economic miracle from all that rubble!
Havel was a God!
by Richard Day on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 1:46pm
If Havel was a God maybe he was Mimir, while Hitchens was Loki
by Elusive Trope on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 1:58pm
Well that's easy.
I hereby render unto Trope the Dayly Line of the Day Award for this Dagblog site, given to all of him from all of me. hahahahaha
by Richard Day on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 2:22pm
The Beastie Boys would say Kim Jong was illin', now he be chillin'. Coulda used a line from Dylan.
by PeraclesPlease (not verified) on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 3:04pm
hahahahahaahahah
I don't know what to do!
Okay, I hereby render unto Peracles the Dayly Poem of the Day Award for this here Dagblog Site, Given to all of Peracles (A great Greek hero, hahahahha) from all of me!
by Richard Day on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 3:35pm
There's a typical Czech pub behind the castle where Havel used to sneak out for a beer in the evening. It can happen in a country of 10 million. I once saw another President putting his grandkids on the train with us. No secret service, no cordons keeping the crowds away. Could have said hi but that would have been tacky.
Perhaps we'd be better off if all our countries were smaller and more human.
by PeraclesPlease (not verified) on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 3:12pm
Perhaps. There is definitely something about developing systems for humans that are on a human scale. Hee. Imagine that. On second thought, that's crazy talk.
by Elusive Trope on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 4:01pm
The Human Scale blog I wrote touched on this a little while ago, in its own clumsy way. The connection between one's elected leaders and the "people" is another dynamic.
by Elusive Trope on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 4:09pm
I read this at Yglesias Moneybox blog today. It makes me want to read more Vaclav Havel:
by EmmaZahn on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 6:45pm
Great passage that shows his ability to tackle the deeply complex fusion of the abstractions in our heads and the ways these abstractions get materialized and perceived in real time. Matt Welsh wrote of Havel:
Havel still played the game of geo-politics, but he at least wrote essays and gave speeches that in essence undermined the very game he was playing. In this manner, he was an intriguing figure on global stage.
by Elusive Trope on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 7:20pm
In the March 90 NYR, an excellent article by Timothy Garton-Ash about the velvet revolution includes a photo of Havel and Dubcek on a balcony together when they have just heard a piece of news about the gradually unraveling of the Soviet Union. Leaning towards one another and smiling. Two good guys.
I was in Prague in Jan of 1990. Havel and the outgoing Communist leader had reached an agreement but even a non-speaker of that language could sense the tension. The taxi driver scoffed at the name of our Hotel clearly because it resembled the name of the nearly-successful resistance movement. There were fresh flowers and lit candles at impromptu shrines, where protestors had been killed the month before. Also, encouragingly, lots of signs clearly saying, "Havel to the Castle."
A month later Havel was here. Me, too. In his case to address Congress (and go to CBGBs). I listened on the car radio. He'd thought of speaking in English, he said, but his staff convinced him it would be a catastrophe, so we would have the chance to hear the beautiful Czechoslovakian language. Then his first Czech words , repeated by the translator, were, "The last time I was in prison."
Great applause from the joint session and me at the wheel for what that's worth.
From the rest of the speech what I recall was his urging Congress to be patient with the Soviet Union because it was moving in the right direction. Of a piece with his recognizing Dubcek and opposing the "lustration"— the hunting down of ex-leaders from the communist regime—which commenced with the very different Vaclav, Vaclav Klaus whose own subsequent very different Premiership caused him to be known as the Czech Margaret Thatcher. For Klaus anyone associated with the former regime—by which he had been comfortably employed—was an enemy until they could prove otherwise. For Havel, until it was proven otherwise, they were human beings trying to get through the day.
That was Havel.
by Flavius on Mon, 12/19/2011 - 10:38pm
Thanks for this remembrance.
For what's it worth I do believe that applauding at the wheel of the car does make a difference just as the poet Jane Hirshfield once said at a reading during the Q&A she has to believe that monk on a rock in the wilderness praying for peace makes a difference.
A poem by Hirshfield, Rebus, comes to mind that seems to me somehow to touch on the journey Havel had in our world
by Elusive Trope on Tue, 12/20/2011 - 1:37am
automatically brought to mind Auden on the death of Yeats. Starting with
not quite true of Havel . Hard not to quote the next few lines
down to
by Flavius on Tue, 12/20/2011 - 7:52am
I hadn't realized this, but Larison reminds us that like Hitchens, Havel supported the invasion of Iraq.
by Donal on Wed, 12/21/2011 - 10:00am
Havel's support of the Iraq invasion has to be included in any assessment or understanding of Havel and his place in history. But to simply conclude that Havel (or anyone for that matter) came to decision because he was a conformist and a yes-man is the type of lazy and usually ideological analysis that make discussing how the Iraq invasion occurred so difficult. Havel's personal experience with totalitarian regimes alone has to be taken into account, when looking into the matter. This doesn't mean that I agree with Havel on this account. I opposed the Iraq operation then and now. But the whole issue has been so politicized that the discussion ends up being closer to a question of whether one believes Cheney and Rumsfeld were visionaries or evil incarnate, and with one's answer showing as Bush said "either you're with us or you're against us."
by Elusive Trope on Wed, 12/21/2011 - 10:29am
I was in Praha in February of 2002 and had heard of Havel. I took a survey questioning local opinions. I asked one person, a tour guide of about 25, what he thought of Havel. He said, "Vaclav Havel is a joke, Vaclav Havel is a shoe shine boy, shoe shine boy, fucking shoe shine boy". I decided not to bring it up anymore.
I can not say for sure what the range of possible statistical error is in my survey and I personally know very little about the man except that he got very good press in the US. So, just sayin'.
by A Guy Called LULU on Wed, 12/21/2011 - 12:11pm
I wouldn't say Havel was perfect and the embodiment of all that was good and decent and wise. He was just another being passing through this world. I think what can be said that regardless of what he did and didn't do, he struggled to do the right thing. Which all we can ask of ourselves, regardless of our positions within the hierarchies of society. On top of that he was able to articulate the aspirational in a powerful way, even if he wasn't always able to achieve it on a personal level.
by Elusive Trope on Wed, 12/21/2011 - 12:22pm