Barth's picture

    Mean Girls (and Boys) and the Mean Women and Men they Have Become

    So that's how it ends. As NBC News White House correspondent Chuck Todd told Chris Hayes last night, the "price" for keeping Congress from cutting its minimal support of Planned Parenthood, was to make further cuts in other programs so that different poor and/or elderly and/or sick people get hurt.

    And, again, we are told this has to be done. The government "needs" to cut its spending during a recession. Just as we "needed" to continue huge tax breaks for the wealthy supported by people who claim to be dedicated to reducing the federal budget deficit. And the programs that "need" to be cut are the ones who aid the people who need the government's help the most.

    Scrooge could not have said it better.

    Your blogger has decided to allow something other than today's news to enter his cranium, lest he explode or otherwise injure himself. It may not be possible, though.

    As it turns out, volume one of the vaunted Autobiography of Mark Twain, which Garrison Keillor decidedly did not like, but which your blogger enjoyed, ended with a 1906 letter from Helen Keller to Mr. Clemens (the author, not the steroid taking pitcher) thanking him for participating in an event in New York to raise funds to help the "adult blind" get useful employment.

    The true message of New York is not the commercial ticking of busy telegraphs, but the mightier utterances of such gatherings as yours. Of late our periodicals have been filled with depressing revelations of great social evils. Querulous critics have pointed to every flaw in our civic structure. We have listened long enough to the pessimists. You once told me you were a pessimist, Mr. Clemens; but great men are usually mistaken about themselves. You are an optimist. If you were not, you would not preside at the meeting. For it is an answer to pessimism. It proclaims that the heart and the wisdom of a great city are devoted to the good of mankind, that in this the busiest city in the world no cry of distress goes up, but receives a compassionate and generous answer. Rejoice that the cause of the blind has been heard in New York; for the day after, it shall be heard round the world.



    Yes, Mr. Clemens, the force of Miss Keller's words will last a thousand years; at least one hundred years so far. But, alas, Mr. Clemens, these one hundred years later, compassion has become a dirty word.

    As has rational thought.

    This is Former Labor Secretary Robert Reich talking to the aforementioned Chris Hayes last night:

    And here is Secretary Reich's further amplification on this point in his own blog:

    All the while, [President Obama] and the Democratic leadership in Congress refuse to refute the Republicans’ big lie — that spending cuts will lead to more jobs. In fact, spending cuts now will lead to fewer jobs. They’ll slow down an already-anemic recovery. That will cause immense and unnecessary suffering for millions of Americans.

    The President continues to legitimize the Republican claim that too much government spending caused the economy to tank, and that by cutting back spending we’ll get the economy going again.

    ... And he continues to draw the false analogy between a family’s budget and the national budget.

    He is losing the war of ideas because he won’t tell the American public the truth: That we need more government spending now — not less — in order to get out of the gravitational pull of the Great Recession.

    That we got into the Great Recession because Wall Street went bonkers and government failed to do its job at regulating financial markets. And that much of the current deficit comes from the necessary response to that financial crisis.

    That the only ways to deal with the long-term budget problem is to demand that the rich pay their fair share of taxes, and to slow down soaring health-care costs.

    And that, at a deeper level, the increasingly lopsided distribution of income and wealth has robbed the vast working middle class of the purchasing power they need to keep the economy going at full capacity.



    President Obama remains, for many of us, a source of hope and inspiration. He is eloquent, intelligent, thoughtful, and well equipped for the tasks at hand. He has been dealt, unquestionably, a difficult hand, dealing with as low rent a Congress as can be remembered even for those with memories that stretch back to the mid 1960s. Indeed, if you did not vote last fall, or, worse, voted for a Republican, you really have no right to complain. You were warned what might happen and what happened was worse than what was imagined by most.

    Still, when the President says that the agreement reached last night insured


    a budget that invests in our future



    or that

    beginning to live within our means is the only way to protect those investments that will help America compete for new jobs -- investments in our kids’ education and student loans; in clean energy and life-saving medical research. We protected the investments we need to win the future



    he knows better and is being generous to people who will not even think about reciprocating the gesture. They will, instead, tell their supporters that the President is a Muslim from Kenya who wants to impose a new socialism on them.

    Even while hoping that this agreement was not reached to protect the high school class whose trip to D.C. the President oddly suggested last night was at least one factor, the landscape he faces, thanks at least in part to all those who stayed home last November, is not a good one. It is even more insane than the public it purports to represent, and just as racist. Moreover, our friends on this side of the political divide need to recognize that our views do not command even the hint of a majority in either house, nor, more than likely, in the rest of the country, as reflected in the opinions of the increasingly idiotic people with whom we live.

    So this will go on and, as Secretary Reich says, the bullies will not be satisfied by concessions. Unhappy with the President as you may be, the only way out of this will be his re-election with coattails that restore Speaker Pelosi and somehow hold the Senate. In the meantime, teeth gritting will have to become fashionable.

    Comments

    Great post, Barth.  That letter from Keller is something else.  Even when good things do happen it's as if we've lost our sense of grandeur about them.


    The other night I saw a PSA aimed at people responsible for hiring folks to consider those with physcial disabilities.  The stigmas and the misconceptions still remain to this day, although great strides have been made. 

    The outcome of the current budget negotiations (should it be put into quotes) is something that does leave a bitter taste in one's mouth, one gets to join the the taste from last November still lingering there.  The socio-political views of the people in this country seem to be taking longer than one might hope to enlighten.  Some great strides have been made, but some steps back, too.  One would hope that a nice crew of FDR populists can ride easily into the House and Senate seats.  But I'm not holding my breath.


    Neither am I, but a guy needs a dream and a hope.  I really feel bad that our gereation has pissed away what our grandparents' generation (at least for me since my parents were barely starting grade school when FDR was elected) gave us.  And, yes, that is why the last 100 pages of the  Twain autobiography, including the Keller letter that abruptly ended it, really shook me, because in his tone as he dictated these things---  blog posts way before blogs really---I saw a guy struggling with same horsebleep one hundred years ago.  He tells a story of a US military outfit in the Phillpines essentially murdering unarmed civilans and the press back here trumpeting all of this as some sort of great military victory for a few days until it styarted to become clear that it was not.  And I can just hear FOX News in the background.


    Don't be so pessimistic.

    Just look at what a party without the presidency, a party without a majority in the Senate, a party without any strong individual leader can do! Massive tax cuts and the greatest spending cuts in history! Total control of the framing of the national debate, and a decent shot at destroying the Great Society. And that's in their first three months...

    The Democrats are powerless because they choose to be powerless. If one day they decide to change their mind, the sky's the limit.


    I'm getting so I can't even listen to regular Democrats talk.

    It's as though their emotions - chiefly despair - have swallowed their brain. The most basic facts of the situation, the bare bones of political power on the ground - that we have the Presidency, they have no obvious leader, we have a majority in the Senate - seem not to even appear on their strategic dashboard. It's as though the Republicans have somehow won power, all power, and we're lost, flailing, going under, making the occasional noble moaning sound as we slip away. 

    There's no confidence. No forward agenda. No taking it to the opposition.

    And it is this, above all for this awful loss of hope, loss of confidence, this caving, this most negative and marginal agenda, that I blame the White House. 

    And to the regular Democratic apologists for this sort of swill, with their pseudo rationalizations and their grand poses as realists - while their fellow citizens are thrown from job and home and good health and any hope for safety - that I wish them a cold day in hell.


    Yeah; sigh.  Dunno if you'll like this, but it gave me a real shot in the arm this morning, though I admit I struggled keeping the images alive.  Peterr writes about Marian Anderson and Eleanor Roosevelt, and what negotiating really can look like, and it means sometimes not negotiating at all, but just making sure the right thing gets done.

    http://firedoglake.com/2011/04/09/lessons-in-negotiations-from-marian-anderson-and-eleanor-roosevelt/


    Yeah, I wrote a blog about this autobiography and Keilor's reactions several months ago:

    http://dagblog.com/arts/hypnotic-rhythms-7940


    This Helen Keller letter just raises my heartbeat a bit! wow

    I am an apologist for our President; I just have seen too many presidents in different shades of right and left and I have witnessed many contexts as they perform in office.

    W Bush was so very, very bad.

    The Reagan Administration contained the worst of the worst as far as leaders that we were forced to see again with w.

    Jerry Ford was just horrible..he vetoed more in his two years than most presidents veto in two full terms under the direction of dicky cheney--the man who would become the biggest embezzler and greatest war criminal of all time.

    I read the news sources everyday...but I have not read the full file!

    I am extremely elated that the repubs are not in the WH, that a teapartier is not in the WH and that McCain aint in the WH.

    I will tell you one thing, I am interested in how this all plays out!

     


    Thanks for that (the link was not good, but I found it and was surprised to have not read it before).  I am going to miss Sam, who has been commuting home with me for a few months reading his stuff through my Ipod to enetertain a tired commuter.

    I hold no grudge for Keillor.  He is a treeasure.  We don't agree on the value of the Twain autobiography.    (The whole Twain thing is beautifully posted here:  http://www.marktwainproject.org/xtf/view?docId=works/MTDP10362.xml;style...

    So, speaking of Harriet Beecher Stowe, as you were in December, but which I just read  ---(one of Clemens' great devices in the autobiography is to to just require you to occupy his time, so I am doing the same)---he had this great story toward the end of the thing about Rev Charles Stowe  (who I assume to be her brother in law) and his son, who the margin notes identify as the writer Lyman Beecher Stowe.  He wrote, I think, in The Nation and was a good lefty rabble rouser.

    This story predates LBS' literary career, and I will let Sam tell it:

     

    Which reminds me of Reverend Charley Stowe’s little boy—a little boy of seven years. I met Reverend Charley crossing his mother’s grounds one morning and he told me this little tale. He had been out to Chicago to attend a Convention of Congregational clergymen, and had taken his little boy with him. During the trip he reminded the little chap, every now and then, that he must be on his very best behavior there in Chicago. He said “We shall be the guests of a clergyman, there will be other guests—clergymen and their wives—and you must be careful to let those people see by your walk and conversation that you are of a godly household. Be very careful about this.” The admonition bore fruit. At the first breakfast which they ate in the Chicago clergyman’s house he heard his little son say in the meekest and most reverent way to the lady opposite him,

    “Please, won’t you, for Christ’s sake, pass the butter?”

     

     


    hahahahah

    We lived in a working class suburb and next door to us--on both sides--was a group of Fundamentalist Christians. Really nice folks.

    We have them over for dinner and my four year-old daughter greeted them at the front door.

    Oh do come in. Daddy is in the kitchen fixing a big ass salad!


    I don't know if you caught the interview with Barbara Boxer who brought it to my attention that RICHARD NIXON signed into law the very women's health program that the repubs are trying to do away with now. I swear, even Ronald Reagan himself couldn't get elected as a repub now. That shows just how nuts they've gone.

    I'm ashamed at the lack of compassion many of those on the right have, and I am also ashamed that the dems don't seem to have the intestinal fortitude to stand up to them. Maybe it's just a lack of numbers, I don't know, but I'm sick to death of the new reality that when you lose, you win, and when you win, you win...but only if you're a repub.

    Good piece. I plan on being around more, and am looking forward to more of your thoughts.


    Latest Comments