The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    Donal's picture

    David Brooks' Last Aid



    I've mentioned National Lampoon's 1973 Last Aid parody before, but I didn't expect anyone to take it seriously.

    1. Don't panic. Move quickly to the side of the deceased. Do not waste valuable time trying to revive him.
    2. Immediately render the deceased immobile. This may be done by pressing a folded blanket or rolled-up coat over his face and holding it in place for at least three minutes or by pinching the nostrils and using mouth-to-mouth asphyxiation.

    In Death and Budgets, David Brooks attempts to apply Last Aid by arguing that living longer is not that worthy a goal.
     

    I hope you had the chance to read and reread Dudley Clendinen’s splendid essay, “The Good Short Life,” in The Times’s Sunday Review section. Clendinen is dying of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, or A.L.S. If he uses all the available medical technology, it will leave him, in a few years’ time, “a conscious but motionless, mute, withered, incontinent mummy of my former self.”

    ... Clendinen’s article is worth reading for the way he defines what life is. Life is not just breathing and existing as a self-enclosed skin bag. It’s doing the activities with others you were put on earth to do.

    But it’s also valuable as a backdrop to the current budget mess. This fiscal crisis is about many things, but one of them is our inability to face death — our willingness to spend our nation into bankruptcy to extend life for a few more sickly months.

    The fiscal crisis is driven largely by health care costs. We have the illusion that in spending so much on health care we are radically improving the quality of our lives. We have the illusion that through advances in medical research we are in the process of eradicating deadly diseases. We have the barely suppressed hope that someday all this spending and innovation will produce something close to immortality.

    Forget all those assurances that American health care is the best in the world. Brooks is here to tell you that (your) life will be nasty and brutish - unless you keep it short. Instead of wasting all our tax money on the illusions of Medicare, Medicaid or ACA, you might as well reduce the surplus population. Let that money go to more useful pursuits, like bailing out banks and financial firms, bailing out TBTF corporations, energy industry subsidies, agribusiness subsidies, the defense industry, and resource wars.

    Do you want to live forever?

    Comments

    "Do you want to live forever?"

    Yes.  And in good condition.  And this is a very worthy goal.  The problem of our health care system is not that goal.  The problem is that, at the rate we're going, if we achieve it, only the rich will be able to enjoy the benefits.  That's the problem.  Mark Zuckerberg living forever but not your neighbor.


    Its funny you bring this up.

    I just began watching Torchwood, something I never heard about (the second installment of ten is on tonight)

    This was a spinnoff from Dr. Who and posits that due to some worldwide virus or plague, people stopped dying.

    Even when you decapitate a burnt body, the head looks up at you anyway?

    I do not see how they are going to get around total cremation from some fire or how someone survives a building falling upon them in such a manner as to turn you into jello--but...

    Unlike Dr. Who, this spinoff appears to be dead serious even though I could not stop laughing.

    ER's fill up, morgues cannot figure out what to do all day, Homicide units become assult specialists...

    Meanwhile on the war front all fighting ends in Somalia whilst N Korea is ready to go into battle with its newfound super army...

    I have been counfounded by the repubs take on universal healthcare (along with certain dem bluedogs) until I figured it out...

    I think you recede into a funk of some kind which brings to mind some old cliches...

    We are all going to die anyway.

    What difference will all this make a century or a millennium from now.

    The poor and the sick and the disabled will always be with us.

    We cannot be everything to everybody and neither can the government.

    Well you get the idea...