In one post above there is a link to Thomas Chatterton Williams criticizing Kali Holloway

Holloway writes for the Nation and supports prison abolition

She admits that she wants the white supremacists put in jail/prison

She recognizes the conflict

In the article, there is a link to an article by two prison abolitionists 

The Atlantic article addresses the conflict

In response to law enforcement’s hands-off approach to the storming of the Capitol on January 6, some on the left have demanded harsher policing of right-wing extremism to match the often-brutal treatment of Black Lives Matter and leftist protest. That is, the very people who supported police reform or outright defunding over the summer seemed to want a crackdown. Skeptics of defunding were quick to point out the apparent contradiction, and they took the opportunity to dismiss the abolitionist position altogether. As the writer Matthew Yglesias mockingly tweeted, “Clearly the answer to yesterday’s failures is to defund the Capitol Police and instead hire a squad of social service providers to tackle the real root causes of the violence.”

But what Yglesias finds absurd, we find imperative. Thinking in terms of root causes and nonpunitive interventions is never ridiculous, even when the target is right-wing extremism.

As a sociologist and an anthropologist who study social control in the United States, we know that punishment can radicalize and further alienate people, while social policy and grassroots community building can defuse potential violence. The abolitionist philosophy is precisely what is missing from the current conversation.

First, we should clear up some misunderstandings. Abolitionists do seek to create a future world in which police and prisons are obsolete, but such long-range commitments do not preclude practical harm-reduction efforts or collaboration with less radical allies. Abolitionists work for incremental improvements, especially interventions that set the stage for more radical change.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/01/stop-right-wing-extremism-without-bolstering-police-power/617759/

I don't see prison abolition happening anytime soon. I do agree that there should be programs that attempt to change criminal behavior. Reading the Atlantic article, I fail to see the cognitive dissonance suggested by Thomas Chatterton Williams. Put the Capitol rioters in jail. The QAnon shaman guy has already been transferred to a prison where he can receive organic food.