MURDER, POLITICS, AND THE END OF THE JAZZ AGE
by Michael Wolraich
Order today at Barnes & Noble / Amazon / Books-A-Million / Bookshop
MURDER, POLITICS, AND THE END OF THE JAZZ AGE by Michael Wolraich Order today at Barnes & Noble / Amazon / Books-A-Million / Bookshop |
I've had enough of the Republican Convention. I'm getting out of Cleveland today and flying to London. So I won't see Trump's speech in real time. I'll just get the replays tomorrow, and spend the next two weeks reassuring frightened Brits that the end of the world is not approaching. (Someone, please, reassure me.)
But it's already clear that the RNC has not gone well for Trump, and even the best speech tonight will, at best, make up part of the ground he's lost. It's been one problem after another, so much so that some aides getting in a car accident on the first day counts as one of the good points. So instead of getting bogged down in the details, let me leave town with four big take-aways from three troubled days:
1. Trump is not the party boss. People are chattering about Ted Cruz not endorsing Trump. But why would anyone expect Ted Cruz to endorse Trump? Cruz never said that he would. The convention started with Cruz's #1 wing man Mike Lee trying to start a floor revolt over the convention rules. But this isn't about Cruz. Trump has not made peace with any of the other major players in the party, and he has no control over them.
Before the convention even started on Monday, Trump's surrogates were attacking prominent Republican office-holders wo had not come to heel. Campaign manager Paul Manafort was berating Ohio Governor John Kasich for boycotting the convention, and getting booed for it by the local crowd. (Pro tip: if Ohio Republicans didn't like Kasich, he wouldn't be Republican Governor of Ohio. QED.) Meanwhile Gingrich was sent out to call the Bush family "childish." That's right. "Childish," coming from the Trump camp, about George H. W. Bush.
These attacks have been a spectacular failure in bringing anyone to heel. Kasich has defiantly avoided the convention and paid the Trumpies back by leaking, on the day Mike Pence accepted the Veep nomination, the news that Kasich had been Trump's first choice for VP and outright refused. So bullying Kasich has just paid off in spades. And what on Earth does Trump think antagonizing the other Republicans will get him? He needs help from these people to turn out the vote, especially since they have GOTV organizations and Trump does not.
Trump has no control over the Republican Party. The Republican Party is currently without a political boss, because Trump hasn't managed to assume that job. He should have made peace with all the rival chieftains in the months before the convention, and come into Cleveland with a show of party unity. Instead, he's operating like a factional leader.
One of the great rules of politics is to take care of business before the meeting. You should not go into the meeting with things unsettled. Yes, I know, there are meetings where things get hashed out, but those are private meetings. Trump should have been having those private hash-it-out meetings for the last three or four months, so that the big public meeting could follow a smooth script. Apparently, Trump was unwilling or unable to make any deals.
More to the point, it's become obvious that the other party players are not afraid of Trump. They can defy him, because they do not fear him. He has no way to punish them, unless he actually becomes President. The level of open defiance from Kasich, Cruz, and several others makes it clear that they are not in the least worried that Trump will be elected. You don't do this to a member of your party who might be President in six months. Cruz and Kasich aren't just betting that Trump will lose. They are completely confident that he will lose.
2. It's personal, not business. Melania Trump's pointless, self-inflicted plagiarism incident is just the most vivid illustration of how Trump World rolls, ignoring the professionals in favor of family members and family retainers. It's not simply that the Trump campaign has not professionalized, which it has not. It's that the inner circle actively vetoes and undermines the attempts at professionalization. The Trump family runs like the Corleone Family would if everyone had to listen to Fredo.
There are some professionals around, but their professional judgment is ignored and they are told instead to enable the amateur insiders' decisions. That misunderstands what professionals are for. They are not there to tell you what you want. They are there to provide expertise that you need and don't have. When a medical doctor gives you his professional advice, you should take it. When a rich client starts telling the doctor that the doctor is paid to do what the patient says, well, that's a rich client who is going to OD on something.
Two professional speechwriters, who had done this before and done it well, wrote a script. Melania, who has no experience with anything like this task, threw out that speech. She then rewrote it with a Trump family retainer who has done some writing but was not at all prepared for a high-stakes task like a major convention speech. So you had a family retainer who wasn't fully qualified operating at the direction, and following the instructions, of a family member who was thoroughly unqualified. Surprisingly, the result was not good.
Then Paul Manafort, one of the allegedly grown-up professionals, was forced to go out and do what the Trumps wanted, which was to flatly and obviously lie for two days, insulting his own intelligence with every word. On the same morning that Manafort had to sit and be called a liar to his face on CNN, the Trumps changed tack and had the family retainer admit to exactly the things Manafort had just denied. The professionals, again, got thrown under the bus.
Professionals only help you if you take your advice. Trump hires professionals to enable his own bad instincts. There is no reason to believe this problem will go away.
3. Trump is still running a primary campaign. It has been shocking how much the Trump convention has been about throwing red meat to the base. Even leaving aside the shocking calls to jail and even kill Hillary Clinton, in a complete break with America's civil politics, the whole show so far has been about riling up the base rather than reaching out to swing voters.
If you didn't know what Benghazi was, or why the Republicans blame Hillary for it, before Monday night, you still wouldn't know after watching this convention. And that's after a solid forty-five minute block of Benghazi programming on Monday. That material wasn't just pitched to the base's biases. It was pitched to people who had already absorbed the fairly complicated conspiracy narrative, which it never really bothered to explain. Even the hate-monging is only for the initiated.
I mean, yes, conventions are meant to get the activists excited, so they will go out and work hard for the campaign. But they are even more important as outreach to the wider electorate. Trump cannot win with just the base of voters who want to imprison Hillary. And what I'm seeing and hearing is a convention that's splitting and alienating even the Republican activists.
I'm not saying he's turning off swing voters. I'm saying he's not even trying to reach them.
4. Losing control of the narrative. Trump needed this convention to change the press's conversation about him, and to dispel the conventional wisdom that he is a disorganized crazy person who's running his campaign into the ground. And the press would be willing, even eager, to go along with that "New Trump" narrative if Trump game them some slight and superficial grounds to go along with it. He doesn't really need to convince the media that he isn't crazy. He just needs to give them something they can use to pretend he isn't. Instead, Trump has gone out of his way to cement the crazy screw-up story. He has done this by 1) being crazy and 2) screwing up.
But it's worse than that. Trump has gotten as far as he has by bullying the media, by rolling them, and by counting on their laziness. When he's called on things, he's turned it around into an attack on the press, and then moved on to the next crazy. Those tricks are beginning to stop working now. They're not effective as they used to be, and sometimes they're counter-productive. The stakes are too high, the stage is too big, and the media have already been lied to so baldly that they're out of free passes to give. At this point, Trump is putting the media in the position of embarrassing him or embarrassing themselves, as he tries to force them to accept his Humpty-Dumpty lies in front of millions of people. They should have stopped accepting his lies a year ago. But he's pushed it to the point where they can't afford to accept his lies even if they wanted to.
Trump's basic communication strategy is signal jamming. He doesn't make a strong case for himself, He just creates so much noise, in the radio-engineer sense of "noise" as static, that no one else can get their message out clearly. That's what happened to the other 16 palookas in the primary. They couldn't make their cases to the public because Trump drowned them out with his endless static.
Hillary Clinton isn't the catchiest tunesmith, but she is a very experienced communicator and she has an enormous broadcast apparatus to send out her message. I expect Trump to spend most of his energies, especially during the Democratic convention, on creating distractions to try to dull Hillary's message. It may or may not work, depending on how the media play along. But what I do know, now, after a year of this nonsense, is that Trump has very little positive signal of his own to broadcast. He can't even get his own children to tell heart-warming anecdotes about him, suggesting that there really may be no heartwarming anecdotes about him. (Compare Melania's speech to the Michelle Obama speech she ripped off; what's missing are all the detailed personal stories Michelle told about her husband, the stories that are the point of the nominee's wife giving the speech in the first place.)
What we are looking at is a fall campaign between a politician and her fine-tuned campaign machine sending out a message about Hillary Clinton, on one hand, and a disruptive troublemaker trying to sabotage that message on the other. There will be no positive Trump vision. If he hasn't shown it by now, he doesn't have one. But Trump will now face trouble sending out even disruptive static, since he has actively trained the press to push back at him hard.
It's an old lesson: you can fool some of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time. I admit I didn't come up with that line myself. I borrowed it from a Republican.
Comments
Brilliant assessment, especially the "signal jamming" metaphor.
by Michael Wolraich on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 2:50pm
The only problem with Doc Cleveland's blogs is they are so good there's usually nothing to add or argue with. I couldn't stop laughing at the last line. Such a subtle dig at the party of Lincoln that says so much.
by ocean-kat on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 3:05pm
I agree with you, OceanKat. I just hope that the Democratic Convention is one of positives and inclusion. The only way it could be worse is for Rudy Guiliani and Chris Christie to rush the stage.
by CVille Dem on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 3:31pm
Thanks, all.
by Doctor Cleveland on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 8:30am
Reading your bullet points, I couldn't help but consider the Clinton campaign based on the same takeaways ...
1. There's no doubt about who holds "boss" status. Nary a one.
2. Nothing is more important to Hillary than running a professional campaign backed up by solid policy and a goal to lead this country to the best of her considerable ability. It's desperate Republicans and disappointed Democrats who want to make it personal.
3. The Democratic primary was over in reality long before it became so on paper - Clinton hasn't wasted a moment looking backward.
4. Losing control of anything is not in Hillary Clinton's DNA.
On to Philadelphia!
by barefooted on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 3:48pm
Agreed on all points.
My only small concern with our convention is how the Bernie delegates will behave.
I am hoping for a drama free convention full of positive messages. I HOPE the convention does not fall into the trap of portraying her as the lesser of two evils. We have a great message of building on the accomplishments of President Obama, inclusion, prosperity and better times for all as we work together, and I would like to see us stay on that message.
by stillidealistic on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 7:58pm
That is my wish and hope as well. We should be able to present ourselves as the adults in the room, with actual policies and plans. I want it to be a positive experience. I still say that the Clinton campaign needs to develop an APP that will let anyone anywhere show what her policies and plans are.
I see why Trump hasn't done that -- he has neither policies nor plans, but for those people who claim ignorance of HRT's plans, why no have an easily accessible answer?
by CVille Dem on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 8:16pm
Absolutely.
I'd quibble over #1, but not really to disagree. I think the Democratic Party does have two bosses: the nominee and the President. They are both clear and undoubted bosses,mane their word goes. But they are very much on the same page. One is about to entire semi-retirement, like Don Corleone, while the other settles the family business.
As for #4, Hillary faces an entrenched media narrative that isn't kind or fair to her. And the press will be very reluctant to let the Hillary-bashing go. I do think that you can, once in a rare while, change the story by changing the reality. If HRC gets out far enough ahead, and Trump keeps melting down, I think the media will have to go with the facts on the ground at a certain point.
by Doctor Cleveland on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 8:40am
I think it's going really well for him. As well as I wanted it to, for sure.
by Michael Maiello on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 3:48pm
Hilarious.
by Doctor Cleveland on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 8:34am
Great post, Doc. I don't know if you meant to do this, but I'm feeling much better now. The media is the key--they have to take some responsibility for their laziness and their greed. "Trump sells" does nothing for the rest of us.
Have a wonderful time in England and please let those Brits know they won't have to worry about Trump. We're on it.
by Ramona on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 4:48pm
Thanks Ramona. At 3 am local time last night I was reassuring a cabbie. And we've only just begun.
by Doctor Cleveland on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 8:34am
What with Brexit he's probably wanting a couch to sleep on. Trump Towers probly isn't it.
by PeraclesPlease on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 9:13am
Great post, and I have nothing to add, except my thanks for pointing out that Cruz and Kasich only feel free to do what they've done because they feel strongly he won't win.
Oh, and enjoy London. I recently returned from a week in Scotland and York, and 2 weeks in London, and nearly every time people heard my accent they asked me what the bloody hell we were thinking by letting Trump this close to the White House. I tried my best to reassure them, but we left right before the Brexit vote, and now that it has passed, and Trump is the actual nominee, they must be more concerned than they were before.
by stillidealistic on Thu, 07/21/2016 - 8:10pm
Thanks. I am enjoying London. Saw Macbeth at midnight last night (still 7 pm Cleveland time) and thought: these two people seem so refreshingly sane.
The real fun will start when our luggage actually gets here. Maybe by the fall?
by Doctor Cleveland on Sat, 07/23/2016 - 8:32am