The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    David Seaton's picture

    The Wikileaks cables: the portrait of an empire

    By David Seaton on Wed, 12/22/2010 - 12:55pm |

    Bwana

    Not really the image that America would like to project at this moment

    There are Wikileaks cables from almost every imaginable part of the world, but since I live in Spain, I'll fill you in on some of the dump's specific effects on Spanish political life.

     

    Just yesterday we saw how the Wikileaks dump has made it impossible for Spanish politicians to pass a stiff law protecting intellectual property, which was one of the primary objects of US pressure on the Spanish government.
    Communications from the U.S. State Department show the U.S. government threatened to blacklist Spain by putting it on its Special 301 list unless its government toughened its anti-piracy laws.  The cables were based on meetings between top Spanish economic ministers, industry representatives concerned about protecting their copyrights and U.S. officials. Spanish editorial writer Esperanza Hernandez wrote this week that Spanish officials “behaved in a way that was subservient in defending the interests of the United States to the detriment of the rights of Spanish citizens to access culture and knowledge through the Internet.” AHN News
    It was never going to be an easy sell, Spain has 20% general unemployment and youth unemployment is estimated at around 40%.  Movie tickets are expensive, at around €8 ($10.50), a typical, legal CD might cost €18 ($25) and a legal DVD of a film  about the same. Bought from a sub-Sahara African street vendor,  operating in a market known as the "Top-Blankets" all these entertainment goods can be had for a fraction of those prices... and downloaded bootleg from the Internet,for the cost of the bandwidth and the virgin disk. An Internet connection sufficient to download films can he had for as little as €20/month. If you consider that average salaries for (employed) workers range from €12,000-€18,000/year, then you can see that legal entertainment is out of the reach of the average working class family, not to mention the unemployed.

     

    Just doing a bit of math you can see that no  Spanish politician in his or her right mind would want to risk his career by  repressing pirate downloads without enormous pressure from the USA. The Minister of Culture was reported publicly wailing that "Obama is worried" about Spanish pirate downloads.

     

    Below are a few more press clippings to give an idea of other ways that  the data-dump specifically affects Spain:
    The US embassy in Madrid pressured Spain to shelve court cases against US government and military officials concerning incidents during the Iraq war and alleged torture at Guantanamo, according to WikiLeaks documents. Monsters and Critics

     

    In what could be the first legal case to use filtered WikiLeaks documents as evidence, the family of a Spanish cameraman killed in 2003 by a US tank shell during the battle for Baghdad filed a complaint Monday. They seek to open an investigation into whether high-ranking officials here colluded with the US Embassy to stop charges being filed against three American soldiers, including a colonel. Christian Science Monitor
    Heavy stuff.

    The story of how the US embassy pressured the Spanish government and judiciary over the News cameraman killed in Iraq is especially galling to Spanish sensibilities:

    Among the cables is one from May 14, 2007, authored by Eduardo Aguirre, a conservative Cuban-American banker appointed U.S. ambassador to Spain by George W. Bush. Aguirre wrote: "For our side, it will be important to continue to raise the Couso case, in which three U.S. servicemen face charges related to the 2003 death of Spanish cameraman Jose Couso during the battle for Baghdad." Jose Couso was a young cameraman with the Spanish TV network Telecinco. He was filming from the balcony of the Palestine Hotel in Baghdad on April 8, 2003, when a U.S. Army tank fired on the hotel packed with journalists, killing Couso and a Reuters cameraman. Ambassador Aguirre was trying to quash the lawsuit brought by the Couso family in Spain. The U.S. ambassador was also pressuring the Spanish government to drop a precedent-setting case against former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and other Bush administration officials. In that same memo, Aguirre writes, "The Deputy Justice Minister also said the GOS [government of Spain] strongly opposes a case brought against former Secretary Rumsfeld and will work to get it dismissed. The judge involved in that case has told us he has already started the process of dismissing the case." These revelations are rocking the Spanish government, as the cables clearly show U.S. attempts to disrupt the Spanish justice system. Ambassador Aguirre told Spain's El Pais newspaper several years ago, "I am George Bush's plumber, I will solve all the problems George gives me." Amy Goodman
    At this writing, former ambassador Eduardo Aguirre is now on the board of Spanish bank operating in the USA.

     

    For someone who is American born and bred, but who lives in Spain and will probably end up as a dual national over here, Wikileaks is very much a mixed bag.

     

    On one hand, having lived abroad most of my life in several different countries, over several decades, I understand that, at least for the moment, the United States of America, with its diplomacy and with its military and economic presence, warts and all, devoid of any of its professed ideological transcendence or "exceptionalism", provides the world with what little real structure it presently possesses*. The leaked cables in their banality are the sound of the world being governed in much the way that the British ruled India. The Wikileaks cables show us clearly, if we ever doubted it, that we are the citizens of a de facto empire, the wilting "Pax Americana".

     

    That is on one hand, and on the other hand, because of what the spam diploma mills of the Internet call "life experience", I am more aware than the majority of Americans that this "governance" of the world is applied mostly without the consent or, much of the time, without even the knowledge of those so "governed". Wikileaks has made official what most informed people have always suspected: the power is in constant use, but functioning under the law of diminishing returns.

     

    We can feel the symptoms all around us: this empire is beginning to crumble and there doesn't seem to be much of anything to take its place. That crumbling sensation and the realization that the world has no "plan B", no viable substitute for the Pax-Americana is what, for me, defines our era. The Wikileaks data-dump has now made this situation clear for all to see.

     

    In a sense this is like the world being told that it has an untreatable disease of uncertain prognosis. No coherent plan of action immediately presents itself. Perhaps ignorance and simply getting on with life would be the better option.  That may no longer be possible.  

    *The United Nations, in which many of us had placed our best hopes for a "world government" appears to have turned into a sort of travel agency for serial rapists.

    Crossposted from: http://seaton-newslinks.blogspot.com

    Comments

    So previously, you did not think that globalization and instant communication tools were radiically changing the world?  It wasn't until wikileaks that you realized this was happening? Helloooo?


    by artappraiser on Wed, 12/22/2010 - 1:09pm

    Well for me it just confirmed what I already suspected and made it more obvious. Kind of like painting that elephant in the room electric green and pink.


    by cmaukonen on Wed, 12/22/2010 - 2:59pm

    Strangely enough, I think the world has changed very little... we are just getting to see "how the sausages are made"... and it won't make a bit of difference.


    by David Seaton on Thu, 12/23/2010 - 12:21am

    I am convinced that only things that actually bring people out into the streets have meaning anymore. We are flooded with "information"... We see it and cluck, "tsk, tsk". Then we go and vote for Tweedledee or Tweedledum... four years later for Tweedledum or Tweedledee. We change channel. We change our brand of aftershave.

    There is this horrible Spanish saying that you cannot deny a man that is being hanged the right to his little dance at the end of the rope. We have found out that Santa Claus does not exist? Mommy and Daddy bring the presents? Do we still want to see the loot under the tree at Christmas? You bet we do! So globalization and instant communication tools are radically changing the world? Plus ça change, plus ça reste la même chose.


    by David Seaton on Thu, 12/23/2010 - 1:05am

    HALaughing


    by cmaukonen on Thu, 12/23/2010 - 9:35am

    You said:

     this empire is beginning to crumble and there doesn't seem to be much of anything to take its place. That crumbling sensation and the realization that the world has no "plan B",


    by artappraiser on Thu, 12/23/2010 - 11:42am

    You seem to be restricting the effects and meanings of globalization in this comment to forms of resistance. This is confusing since the subject was brought up in response to the scene you draw of pax americana coming to an end through the process of globalization.  In some fashion, aren't you arguing against your own position?

     


    by moat on Thu, 12/23/2010 - 5:58pm

    Spanish editorial writer Esperanza Hernandez wrote this week that Spanish officials “behaved in a way that was subservient in defending the interests of the United States to the detriment of the rights of Spanish citizens to access culture and knowledge through the Internet.

    "Interests of the United States" should probably be read as "interests of the RIAA."


    by Orion on Sun, 01/09/2011 - 5:15pm