The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    cmaukonen's picture

    Divisions ÷



    One day Chuang Tzu and a friend were walking by a river. "Look at the fish swimming about," said Chuang Tzu, "They are really enjoying themselves."

    "You are not a fish," replied the friend, "So you can't truly know that they are enjoying themselves."

    "You are not me," said Chuang Tzu. "So how do you know that I do not know that the fish are enjoying themselves?"

    It has become almost a cliche' that this country is divided and seems to becoming even more so with each passing day. And that our government is becoming less and less responsive to the public as a whole. There have been a number of reasons suggested for this. The media seems to be a big one, thought I personally cannot put all of the responsibility on it alone.

    Let's look instead at what has changed in the course of the last 50 years or so.  These are just a few things that come to mind.

    • For the first time we have a large number or people from a generation that has had to do little if any physical work to make a living. Neither has there parents. That none in their immediate family has worked a Blue Collar   job. Probably has no even done anything more stressful than flip burgers while they were in high school.  Did not have a parent that worked in a factory or mill or even on a farm.

    • A generation that was not required to be in the military.  "The United States discontinued the draft in 1973, moving to an all-volunteer military force, thus there is no mandatory conscription." - Wikipedia

    • That has a parent that was in WWII or went through the depression of the 1930s. To them this is just something that they might have read about in history class.

    • That has any memory of the Cold War years. Where being blown to radio active dust was a real possibility.

    Add to this that ethnic divisions have grown as the number and diversity of the people who have immigrated has has increased of the the last 30 years or so.  Bringing in Muslims and Hindus and Asians and people from the former Soviet Block  countries.  Areas that had little ethnic diversity now have a lot more. With Latino and Asian populations where just 30 years ago there were mainly white and maybe black populations only.

    A drastic decrease in unionized blue collar jobs that had been integrated for a significant time.  Being replaced with white collar and semi professional jobs that have not been so ethnically diverse.  Jobs that had never been unionized because it was never seen as necessary.

    The biggest division I see is the one along class line. And by this I don't mean just economic but also cultural.  A large group of people who along with their parents and grand parents were able to attend college and become doctors and lawyers and executives and engineers and technicians and what not. Living far away from the cities and the farms and the working class areas of past generations.  For whom the American Dream was coming true but now see it Slip Sliding Away.

    All this added to the racial and geographic divisions had already existed and were never really dealt with or legislated. We have a situation that will be difficult to rectify easily.
     

    Comments

    And yet 75 percent of Tea Party supporters are over the age 45 (with 29 percent over the age of 64). I suspect that most of them remember the Cold War--unless dementia has set in. Most of the pro-labor lefties ain't spring chickens either.

    As for the new generation you speak of, I believe that its members tend towards apathy. Blame 'em for ignorance if you like, but don't hold them accountable for the bitter political divisions of recent years.


    Then we are talking baby boomers and there younger siblings then. Interesting. But these are the first generation to get higher education in any numbers. Also those involved with the civil rights movement and anti war movement.

    To quote Dr. Morbius "How ironic."


    Perhaps conventional wisdom is unenlightened. How can there be division if everyone agrees the country is divided or if everyone agrees the government is becoming less and less responsive? The population you speak of are Chuang Tzu's fish.

     


    I think that one thing that we are divided on is what to do about it. But since no one really has a clue, how can we even be divided on that ?

    Rather like The barber Paradox.


    We swim in turbulent waters. For some, there are warm currents, for some cold. For some, predators lurk behind every rock, for some, there are calm tides and plentiful foodstuffs, but we are all swimming in the same ocean.  How can there not be division on what to do? What we have lost, it seems to me, is the desire to all strive together for the common good; to be the school of fish rather than individual fishes... or have I tortured the metaphor too much? 


    So we are where we are today because we didn't achieve a better standard of living like what was given to us by those who came before because we didn't work as hard as they did to create something of value to pass on to the next generation.

    Interesting idea that has some legs to it. What we have today is the fruition of the change in work ethics we selected instead of following the pattern passed on by other successful generations.