I'm usually the last one to panic when things go from haywire to havoc.
I'm the one who's out there directing traffic, shushing, patting
shoulders, plumping pillows, digging in my pockets for
chocolate--whatever it takes.
I don't see the tunnel, I see the
light at the end. If there's a rainbow in the sky, I'll look past the
dark clouds and find it. Pollyanna and I are BFFs, for God's sake. But
when I see a Nobel-laureate in Economics practically self-immolating on
the White House lawn in order to be heard, I'm not just scared, I'm
petrified.
I
don't know if Paul Krugman is right when he says the White House is
going about this banking debacle all wrong, and that we're near the
edge of the Cliff of Doom. One misstep, he seems to be saying, and it's
all over. He's not the only one saying it, of course. If he were, I
might go back to singing my comfort songs and handing out bonbons.
There
are two camps now, each of them filled with "experts", each of them
plucking ideas out of thin air and calling them "solutions". Their
voices are ringing across a battleground, over our heads. We hear them
shouting in a strange, incomprehensible language: "TARP bailout"
"Zombie banks", "toxic assets", "Cash for Trash". . .
We want at
least one of them to come over to our side and give us a heads up. What
the hell is going on? What's going to happen? Are we or aren't we doomed?
This was the week it all hit the fan. Lots of voices out there shouting
messages to Obama, and Obama, strangely, answers back with his version
of "Heck of a job, Brownie". On "60 Minutes" last Sunday there was this
exchange with Steve Kroft:
Kroft:Your Treasury
Secretary, Tim Geithner, has been under a lot of pressure this week,
and there have been people in Congress calling for his head. Have there
been discussions in the White House about replacing him?
President Obama: No.
Kroft: Has he volunteered to or come to you and said, "Do you think I should step down?"
President Obama:
No, and he shouldn't. And if he were to come to me, I'd say, "Sorry,
buddy, you still got the job." But look, he's got a lot of stuff on his
plate, and he is doing a terrific job. And I take responsibility for not, I think, having given him as much help as he needs.
That was wince-worthy and I was wincing. One of those
could-come-back-to haunt sound bite traps that Obama should know better
than to fall into .
On Monday Paul Krugman wrote a piece in the NYT called
"Financial Policy Despair"
He said, " If the reports are correct, Tim Geithner, the Treasury
secretary, has persuaded President Obama to recycle Bush administration
policy -- specifically, the "cash for trash" plan proposed, then
abandoned, six months ago by then-Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson.
This is more than disappointing. In fact, it fills me with a sense of despair. "
That can't be good.
Non-economist Frank Rich
wrote a column this week
called "Has a 'Katrina Moment' arrived?". He said, "Bob Schieffer of
CBS [asked Larry Summers] the simple question that has haunted the
American public since the bailouts began last fall: "Do you know, Dr.
Summers, what the banks have done with all of this money that has been
funneled to them through these bailouts?" What followed was a monologue
of evasion that, translated into English, amounted to: Not really, but
you little folk needn't worry about it. Yet even as Summers spoke,
A.I.G. was
belatedly confirming
what he would not. It has, in essence, been laundering its $170 billion
in taxpayers' money by paying off its reckless partners in gambling and
greed, from Goldman Sachs and Citigroup on Wall Street to Société
Générale and Deutsche Bank abroad."
Money-laundering? Isn't that illegal?.
Even-handed
Eugene Robinson--no economist, either, it must be said--doesn't think
we've quite reached the cliff edge yet, but he's not ruling out the
possibility. In the Washington Post today he
wrote a column
called, "The Repairman's Burden". He said, "Geithner's plan offers
private investors the opportunity to reap relatively big gains by
taking relatively small risks. Some of the risk is assumed by
taxpayers. Christina Romer, head of the Council of Economic Advisers,
said over the weekend that these private firms will be doing the
government a favor by participating in the program. But that's wrong.
Investors will participate because they think they can make money. The
only entity that's doing anyone a favor -- make that doing
everyone a favor -- is the government of the United States. "
Romer: "private firms doing the Government a favor". Are you thinking what I'm thinking?
When
they're talking about billions and trillions they're talking way over
my head. I barely understand the concept of millions. I don't
understand economics, or banking, or bailouts, or almost anything to do
with Big Money. But what I'm hearing these days is panic and
frustration among the cognoscenti. They see things that we don't see,
and we're counting on them to make sure we get this right.
Somebody
has to have a handle on this crisis. So far, nobody does. I don't know
about you, but I would feel a whole lot better if I knew that President
Obama was at least willing to listen to those whose opinions differ
from his chosen few. His Washington insider choices for top cabinet
positions made little old me nervous right from the start. When the new
"Change" president puts former Big Business people in charge of
regulating Big Business, even the dumbest among us sees trouble ahead.
So
give a little listen, Mr. President. It can't hurt. These are your
friends, remember. They're all talking about you, anyway. Better to
have them in front of you than behind your back.
Ramona