The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    David Seaton's picture

    Poor United States, so far from God and so close to... the USA

    The lesson of the past few years: Watch out for things that can go massively wrong. What could go massively wrong in 2011? Let's start next door, with Mexico.  Mexico drug war a nightmare scenario - CNN

    I put the quote above, one that I have taken at random from CNN, to avoid being accused of setting up a straw man -- the idea that no one in the USA is worried about the Mexican drug war. Plenty of people are very worried, and for all the right reasons. All I want to do here is add some more reasons of my own to be worried. 

    Many people fear, and they have good reason to do so, that Mexico may be in danger of becoming a "failed state", or may already be one to some extent. I am not that optimistic, I think that the real danger may be that the United States of America is in danger of becoming a "failed state" or may already be one to some extent and that Mexico's dilemma is in great part only a symptom of America's own dilemma.

    This is really not all that complicated:

    What is happening in Mexico is because of unsolved problems in the USA.

    Americans consume 60 percent of the world's illegal drugs. Quaker.org

    Ye Quakers really hath got this one all figured out:

    Drugs are the ultimate consumer product for people who want to feel good now without benefit of hard work, social interaction, or making a productive contribution to society. Drug dealers are living out the rags-to-riches American dream as private entrepreneurs desperately trying to become upwardly mobile. That is why we could not win the war on drugs. We are the enemy, and we cannot face that fact. So we launched a half-hearted, half-baked war against a menace that only mirrors ourselves. Quaker.org

    So it turns out that the Americans have an insatiable appetite for drugs -- unmatched in all the world -- seemingly bottomless pockets to pay for the stuff, after which, the American banks launder the drug money, and then to top it off, the US gun dealers take this laundered money and sell the Mexican drug lords the military grade weapons to fight off the Mexican army and police and to murder some 30,000 people in the last four years. Really you'd have to ask yourself which of the two states failed first, Mexico or the USA?

    But all of this is the easy part... when states fail to deliver reasonable governance to this degree, when a state is what I call "bath tub ready", what follows is difficult to predict beyond its messiness.

    Here is a possible scenario of political "science fiction":

    Over the last few years, the drug gangs of Mexico have developed into very sophisticated paramilitary organizations with expertize in counter-surveillance, counter-intelligence, recruiting and corrupting public officials, confronting conventional military power, money laundering, clandestine transnational movement of men and materiel, financial engineering and communications of  all kinds, not just their primary skill set of torturing and killing people and blowing things up.

    A large number of poor young Mexicans, both men and women, without a great deal to look forward to in life, are joining these organizations, where they are being exposed to and being trained in the above mentioned skills to a high degree. This might be the proper place to point out that these are the typical organizational and operating capabilities of a national liberation movement. It would appear that developed countries' addiction to illegal recreational drugs is the natural way to finance revolutionary activity in the underdeveloped countries that produce or transport those drugs... That is how the Taliban finance their long running war against the United States, by the way. Here might also be a good place to point out that traditional South American revolutionary movements such as Colombia's FARC and Peru's "Shining Path" already finance themselves by catering to American's love of cocaine and that neither Colombia nor Peru share Mexico's vibrant revolutionary traditions.

    So it might be logical to postulate that if a contemporary Emiliano Zapata were to appear among the poor of  Mexico, he or she would almost certainly spring from the ranks of the young people who are being armed and trained by the Mexican drug lords. Many commentators accuse the FARC and the Shining Path guerrillas of being nothing more than drug gangs disguised as revolutionaries... perhaps to win the sympathy of Mexican poor, the Mexican drug lords might consider donning such a disguise themselves. Or perhaps one of their number might have a genuinely patriotic epiphany... Who knows? But the temptation would be great. As we know in the United States, wrapping oneself in the flag is... why continue?

    But however such a development took place it would lead to outcomes much worse than anything that the Middle East or South West Asia could ever dish up. Nothing that Al Qaida or any Islamic organization could execute would ever destabilize life in the USA even a fraction of what a well funded, well armed and sophisticated revolutionary movement in Mexico could.

    Imagine what sort of nativist paranoia and racist hysteria would result if only one single Mexican woman ever blew herself up in a crowded shopping center in Los Angeles. Impossible you say, suicide bombers are always Muslim fanatics going for the 72 virgins in Islamic paradise... Sorry, but the exploding vest, the most effective terrorist weapon ever developed was the invention of Sri Lanka's Tamil Tigers, a secular, nationalist liberation movement. Globalization means the free movement of ideas, remember?


    In the 1990s as the Russians lost control of their traditional spheres of influence; the world witnessed the seemingly magic disintegration of the czarist empire that Russia had maintained through world wars and revolution since the 17th century. The similarities to the deflation of US power in Latin America are striking. If anything defines the times we are living through it is that the unthinkable and the unbelievable not only can happen, they are almost sure to happen, just as sheep are cloned and the New York skyline is fractured.

    But remember, what happens in Mexico is financed by the American hunger for chemical release from their daily lives and armed by the greed of American arm dealers, who are unrestrained because the American political system is paralyzed by special interest lobbies.


    The United States is the world's richest, most powerful country, only the United States can defeat or destroy the United States... "Heck of  job Uncle Sam!"

    Crossposted from: http://seaton-newslinks.blogspot.com/

    Comments

    One thing to consider is the drug cartels don't want to be the government.  Some of them, given their level of military weapons etc could have pulled off political coups along time ago.  But there is no benefit to them to take over the state. Just a lot of headaches.  Like the mafia in Sicily in the old days or the mob in Russia, they prefer to be a shadow government, controlling only those things which increase their profits, but able to operate outside the bounds of the "law" without having to at least make the appearance that they are behaving as a legitimate government of the people.   In Mexico, their preference would be that government just go back to not trying to seriously intervene in their business, take the bribes and go home. 

    My personal opinion is that if some Zapata would appear that the cartels thought would lead to the US bringing the full force of its military down on them, this Zapata-like individual would just end up in some ditch pretty quickly.  Think of all the violence that is happening just on the other side of the border, and yet almost none of it spills over the invisible line on US soil.  A big reason for that is that the drug lords know it is in their best interest not to give any reason for a larger US involvement in what is happening there.  If the US actually went to war with the drug cartels (think drones flying over the Mexican sky), the cartels wouldn't stand a chance.  At the very least they couldn't live the lavish lifestyles they currently do.  Most them are not willing to live in caves like Osama. 

    All of this doesn't diminish the significance of the drug problem in this country, nor the arms industry that supplies these paramilitary forces operating south of the US border.  But ultimately it is not in the interest of the cartels for Mexico to become a truly failed state, just as it isn't in the Russian mob's interests that Russia's government implodes. 


    What you say Another Trope, makes a lot of sense.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Romana

    The United Nations acts in the same way.

    The United Nations has 192 Member Countries.The 5 permanent members - China, France, the Russian Federation, the United Kingdom and the United States can block any proposal brought before the Council by casting a negative vote or block. 

    Earth- wide cartels control everything. Banking, oil, arms, drugs, in what ever commodity, wherever supply and demand can be manipulated. 

    The Cartels can control without direct governance. The cartels are not interested in social services, or garbage collection, sewers, or healthcare or retirement other than their own. 

    They are merchants; the only thing they are interested in is profit.

    “Merchants have no country. The mere spot they stand on does not constitute so strong an attachment as that from which they draw their gains.”
    Thomas Jefferson

    Peace and harmony helps maintain they’re profitability, discord interrupts business.

    As long as the government leaves them alone, there’ll be peace.

    Take the profit out of drug distribution, and the drug cartels are out of business.

    The war on drugs only controlled supply. Less supply and the more profit.

    Governments controlled by Cartels, can control supply and the price being charged for those who demand.


    Over the last few years, the drug gangs of Mexico have developed into very sophisticated paramilitary organizations with expertize in counter-surveillance, counter-intelligence, recruiting and corrupting public officials, confronting conventional military power, money laundering, clandestine transnational movement of men and materiel, financial engineering and communications of  all kinds, not just their primary skill set of torturing and killing people and blowing things up.

    You note this mirrors the activities of the Talaban.

    And I might add they are just emulating those at the DOD along with its contractors. ha

    Get out there and make some money, damn the regulators, full speed ahead.

    That seems like the message from the repubs and the drug dealers are just attempting to put the message into force.


    Suggestion to retitle this:

    America's going to fall soon into total chaos one way or another, I've just got to find out how (Post # 843 in a series.)

    Segue to main text: The sky could be falling! The sky could be falling!

    A request: Call me when the Zapata turns up and convinces the drug lords and their employees to go Marxist and make war on their golden goose, American drug users. No wait--scratch that--call me early. before the Marxist conversion, when they manage to breach the barricades of the Riviera Maya and Puerto Vallarta.


    p.s. Despite the fact that the article you chose "at random" to start with is by David Frum, not someone I would normally look to for astute analysis about Mexico, It would be a great post if it stopped at

    Plenty of people are very worried, and for all the right reasons.....Many people fear, and they have good reason to do so, that Mexico may be in danger of becoming a "failed state", or may already be one to some extent

    and left out the movie script fantasy stuf:  If anything defines the times we are living through it is that the unthinkable and the unbelievable not only can happen, they are almost sure to happen, just as sheep are cloned and the New York skyline is fractured.Talk about fearmongering, sheesh. It's like your avatar should be a cartoon of a guy sweating and biting his nails:, what if what if what if what if this bogeyman or that bogeyman comes...


    I don't see Marx in any of this, I do see rebellion at many levels fueled by endless cash and I see growing dystopia on both sides of the border. And as I try to point out, this is not the Mexican's fault, this problem has all its origins in the USA... and I think that many young Mexicans must be aware of this... how American drug addiction is destroying their country. The forces at work here are all negative, destructive. The fuse is lit.


    Art,
    Day to day life is so banal in the USA that it is difficult to believe that anything truly horrible that happens "out there" could actually affect that day to day life... despite 9-11, when the sky really did fall. Chemicals are not the only drug Americans take in quantities... the who society is constructed as a drug.

    What happens in Mexico is much more important than what happens in Afghanistan, Pakistan or Iran... Millions of American citizens are of Mexican descent or immigrants from that country. The tensions in the American South West are palpable. Remember that Mexicans didn't cross the border, the border "crossed them". As this insane violence begins to spill over the frontier and into the USA... Just put the pieces out on the table in front of you and put the puzzle together yourself... tell me if you see a pretty picture.

    BTW. Get up to speed on your Mexican geography, it's a very big country. The Riviera Maya and Puerto Vallarta are not "norteña"... If all this shit was happening down in Chiapas or Yucatan, it wouldn't have the same effect USA/Mexico, Mexico/USA that it does.


    I think the interrelated/causal relationship of the US to Mexico's problems are manifest as you point out.  Mexico, while poor is however, nowhere near the bottom of the world's economies in terms of human development, and with a growing middle class, I doubt any drug cartel(s) will morph into a revolutionary force in this country.  Were they to do so, I'm sure the cartel leaders understand that the US would feel free, and likely be invited by the Mexican government, to participate in military and paramilitary operations against them.  This is something even the most vengeful cartel leaders would likely wish to avoid at all costs.  You might enjoy reading Chris Floyd's/Ben Ehrenreich's recent take on the situation south of the border if you haven't read it.

    I do think that you're not far off in describing the United States as a potentially failed state on many different levels, I just think your take on Mexico is a tad skewed.


    The Quakers may be right about their take on drug dealers, but on this:

    "Drugs are the ultimate consumer product for people who want to feel good now without benefit of hard work, social interaction, or making a productive contribution to society" --I think they're way off the mark.

    They lump all drugs together, for one thing, and 'drugs' are very different in their effect, price, average consumer demographic, and usage.  People take drugs for a varitety of reasons: pleasure/entertainment, relaxation, pain management, and sometimes because they're illegal, as in the case of some teenagers. 

    The most nihilistic drugs are taken by people who simply don't want to be themselves, often because they have no jobs, no hope, no education, maybe no family.  Shorter: they don't like their lives. 

    Cocaine is a status symbol by now: if you can buy coke for your parties, you have arrived, dude!

    Drug cartels and violence only enter the equation because we keep them criminal.  Kids in the ghetto become drug runners because they're illegal.  The war on drugs has always been a failure because so many law enforcement people are corrupt and protect the trade. 

    It's a huge business, and we spend as much on the sham Drug War as Americans spend on illegal drugs every year.  It's not just the phony pretending-to-be-moral politicians who don't want drugs decriminalized: it's the people profiting from the war on drugs, guaranteeing 'We' will never win it.


    What is amazing is that Americans take 60% of the world's illegal drugs... That has to be sick. What levels of alienation does that imply?