The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    wws's picture

    ORACLES

    Donal has reminded us how prescient George Orwell and Aldous Huxley were in their imaginings of the future. To that roster of insightful seers I would like to add Doris Lessing, who wrote The Golden Notebook in 1962.

     Perhaps Lessing's book (for which she won a Nobel prize) is less often thought of as oracular because it was originally lauded, and is still often referred to, as a groundbreaking study of mid-20th century feminism. That it also examined the early days of awareness of wrong and a resistance to apartheid in Africa, as well the rise and fall of the Communist Party in western cultures was duly noted, but these areas of focus in the book were apparently deemed secondary in the minds of reviewers.

     Having just reread it -- because there are four, not three notebooks in the book and I had a distinct recollection that it addressed yet another theme, one that might seem timelier now than then -- I  can attest that, in fact, The Golden Notebook is filled with foreboding, if not outright predictions, that (I paraphrase) "a combination of political naîvité on the part of a passive and/or too readily impressionable populace, together with a stealthy consolidation of control in government, might well cause the end of democracies as we know them. "

     Here are just a few excerpts from Lessing's text that make that point:

    "I sat there, discouraged and depressed. Because in all of us brought up in a Western democracy there is this built-in belief that freedom and liberty will strengthen, will survive pressures, and the belief seems to survive any evidence against it. This belief is probably in itself a danger. ....

    I thought of all the people I knew well, some of them fine people; many of us had been sunk inside communist conformity.... while the 'liberal' or 'free' intellectuals  could be and had been swung into witch hunts of one kind or another. Very few people really care about freedom, about liberty, about the truth - very few. Very few people have guts, the kind of guts on which a real democracy has to depend. Without  people with that sort of guts a free society dies....

    Sitting there, I had a vision of the world with nations, systems, economic blocks hardening and consolidating; a world where it would become increasingly  ludicrous even to talk about freedom, or the individual conscience.  I know that this sort of vision has been written about - it is something one has read - but for a moment it wasn't words, ideas, but something I felt, in the substance of my flesh and nerves, as true...." 

    The Golden Notebook is a treasure trove of cultural  observation and analysis. If you haven't read it, please do.  And if you know of other books in which stranger- -than- fiction predictions seem suddenly relevant, please share them here.

    Comments

    Nice, WW; no wonder you are such a fan. Eerily prescient, wasn't she?
    '...very few care...about the truth.' Yeppers.
    Another dystopian was Kurt Vonnegut, Player Piano in particular. But worse than being replaced by machines, many workers are replaced by off-shoring. And not so much above by engineers and business bosses, because money is made by selling the phoney derivatives-of-money.

    p.s. Can I see the Golden Notebook in video?


    I don't know this book. But Lessing did write some of the best and most social relevant science fiction of the 20th century. The books have never been taken as seriously as they should have because of the genre.


    Definitely a must read for everyone. One of the first "influential" books to come my way when I first entered college many moons ago. It has been awhile, so I should probably read it again. One of the lasting impressions of the book was that it captured the real attempt to navigate the world as it is while trying to better that world at the same time maintaining one's autonomy and connections to others, looking for road maps and discovering the maps we do have aren't exactly accurate. In other words, there are no easy answers, in love or in war. Disillusionment comes easy.


    “. Because in all of us brought up in a Western democracy there is this built-in belief that freedom and liberty will strengthen, will survive pressures, and the belief seems to survive any evidence against it”

    Liberty ?? Common goals can’t even be defined?

    How is it that we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of negroes?
    en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Samuel_Johnson

    The book I recommend is the Holy Scriptures of the Bible

    (Ecclesiastes 8:9) 9 All this I have seen, and there was an applying of my heart to every work that has been done under the sun, [during] the time that man has dominated man to his injury. . .
    (Jeremiah 10:23) . . .to earthling man his way does not belong. It does not belong to man who is walking even to direct his step.

    Acamus had a recent post
    http://tpmcafe.talkingpointsmemo.com/talk/blogs/a/c/acamus/2009/12/ive-always-been-partial-to-wha.php#more

    It included a link to Godot, very soul searching.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WoC9Kx5QvK0

    (Romans 8:20) 20 For the creation was subjected to futility, not by its own will but through him that subjected it, on the basis of hope

    Can oracles tell us why, so we can avoid problems?


    Wendy,,

    I'm going to try and get a copy of this.

    Wise women (you and Lessing), we need many more! (And of course, more than three wise men!)

    Greatly appreciate.


    I have to come back to this Belle.It sounds like a really fine read.

    Today Matthews just quoted Yogi Berra:

    We are lost but we are making good time.

    hahahahaah


    That's funny
    Always an optomist


    Acumus -- I couldn't have said it better. Thanks.


    Now you see; there you go. I've read all of Lessing, more than once but...not her science fiction. Maybe there her prescient thought is most obvious. I'll read it, starting tomorrow. Thank you.


    Oops, this was a reply to Doomer, just below. But, Wendy, I've also been rereading Vonnegut, and I admire him more now than before.
    What is the lesson? Perhaps that we are egocentric when we think that current circumstance is unique.


    Thanks for this Wendy - very thought-provoking as always. I have a great site for used books; in fact they have "The Golden Notebook" for $1 plus shipping of $2.65.

    It is abebooks.com, and I can vouch for it; I've gotten quite a few bargains and all the books were in great shape.


    From page 608. I haven’t read this book Staebler, (but I will.) However, your quotes and these few pages certainly give a good feel of the book. One lovely quote that struck me as positive oracle:

    “After a while I realized I was doing what I had done before, creating the “third” - the woman altogether better than I was. For I could positively mark the point where Ella left reality, left how she would, in fact, behave because of her nature; and move into a large generosity of personality impossible to her. But I didn’t dislike this new person I was creating; I was thinking that quite possibly these marvelous, generous things we walk side by side with in our imaginations could come in existence, simply because we need them, because we imagine them. Then I began to laugh because of the distance between what I was imagining and what in fact I was, let alone what Ella was.”

    From The Golden Notebook


    Because in all of us brought up in a Western democracy...

    Ms. Lessing's foresight may be 20/20, but her hindsight is apparently dim. She grew up in Persia and Rhodesia, neither of them "Western democracies," and it's probably a mistake to assign the narrative voice of the Golden Notebooks to "Doris Lessing," ex-wife of the East German Ambassador to Uganda, and an extraordinarily mixed-up personality at every stage of her long, long, long and mixed-up life.


    George: imo, what is magnificent about the human spirit -- male or female in its derivation -- is in that capacity to learn, to understand and play forward a more inclusive view of life. Not one predicated on one's own limited experience, in whatever venue, but one that stretches beyond personal experience to what is, dare I say it, universal.
    Color me naive; inspiration is never found in negativity, to which I am so prey; rather, inspiration is found in transcending the obvious to that which just might benefit all.
    End of sermonette. But I do actually believe this.


    Ha. Can't get the link to work here.
    If you want to read some more,
    go to google books, type in
    "The Golden Notebook" (inside quotation marks).


    Strato: the particular quote you cite is, in fact, my personal Achilles heel and perhaps that of most of us, both male and female: what happens or, more importantly, what may we expect to happen when on our own -- without invitation or overt demand -- we transcend our limited selves (whether, as we think at the time, for the beloved other, or, egocentrically, simply to prove to ourselves that we can, as it were, go the extra mile) only to discover that, in fact, it is only our own self-test, that no one else has noticed, or in fact gives a damn?
    Lessing's Ella is real to us all. But beyond the recognition of painful chagrin, what lesson is to be learned from this exercise?


    C'Ville: as they say in the south: "Praise Jesus." The library is well-intentioned but causes one to fret in terms of immediate gratification. And the librarians are so humorless when it comes to margin notes, underlinings or bent tabs. Thank you, then, for this link.


    Resistance: I think they can, if we would only listen. What do you think?


    I'm not disillusioned. I'm just mad that a few have hijacked the many. I mean really really MAD.

    I try to reread 1984 and Brave New World at least once a decade, because I seem to have a different take on it as I age, things I didn't see before.

    I will try to pick up a copy of Lessing.

    Thanks ma'am.


    Sounds to me that a history like that would give her more insight, not less.

    YMMV

    Most of us mere mortals start life mixed up and stay that way. We can admire those that transcend that confusion. Unless, of course, we are damn sure we know it all

    Eh, 'George?'


    Well…the energy available to us is both negative and positive. We operate with both. We’re just electrical, surging this way and that. We can use either direction and transform it toward the good. Of course that line wavers but we reach for it anyway. Synchronicity exists and energy builds on itself. So I just look at it as available energy without judging the merits and go from there. (Lessons learned plunging into depressions and suffering physical pain.) What works for me is a kind of temporary judgmental detachment from events, viewing them as extremely “interesting” at least until I can get creative and work my way up and out of a negative state of mind.

    When I write I often use a highly negative impetus (like Palin last night). But changing it is fun and during the forward motion I feel better. When someone, me or you or anyone, gets a good vibe, that’s the best. We’re all part of the same energy, so when you laugh, even with painful chagrin, we join in some marvelous exchange of energy. We’re all connected and affect each other in zillions of ways and I give a very large hot-damn! how it feels to be here exchanging energy with you and Doris Lessing and everyone else, yes even George. A negative view is just another part of the energy field - a place we bounce new ideas from.


    I will never, ever forget Slaughterhouse 5; I did not know until tehn about the fire-bombing of Dresden.


    hahahaha

    I have trouble with eyes


    hahah


    Bwak -- that's what seems so wonderful about reading in conjunction with greater age and/or experience (not to mention lost brain cells) -- a book is new, again.


    I agree Wendy. I reread Slaughterhouse Five just a few months ago. Either I wasn't paying attention the first time or it is only now that what he wrote touched me. What images (the cart amidst the rubble looms large for me) affected you?


    Definitely the bit in the preface where he describes writing each character's story in crayon on a long roll of paper and then everything gets hashed together at Dresden.

    An image so powerful that I haven't forgotten about it since I read the book in high school.

    Poo-tu-weet.


    Vonnegut's 'Hocus Pocus' was one of his unsung classics, in which he portrayed a future world in which the US has subcontracted out the running of all federal prisons to a Japanese firm. Vonnegut saw the move toward privitization of public services clearly only a short time after Ronnie Reagan slept his way through 8 years of the US presidency.

    The protagonist "is fired from his job as a college professor after having several of his witticisms surreptitiously recorded by the daughter of a popular conservative commentator. Eugene then becomes a teacher at a nearby overcrowded prison run by a Japanese corporation. His employer, and occasional acquaintance, is the prison's warden, Hiroshi Matsumoto. After a massive prison break, Eugene's former college is occupied by escapees from the prison, who take the staff hostage. Eventually the college is turned into a prison, since the old prison was destroyed in the breakout. Ironically, Eugene is ordered to be the warden of the prison, but then becomes an inmate, presumably via the same type of "hocus pocus" that led to his dismissal from his professorship."

    Kurt Vonnegut was one of the good ones. Prescient, while still maintaining a sense of humor. No mean feat.


    Thanks, Mh2o -- I haven't read that one. I will.
    Happy Trails.


    Great quote. So apropos.


    I've not read it.... yet! Thanks for the tip.

    The Unholy Trilogy:
    - Brave New World (Huxley)
    - 1984 (Orwell)
    - The Handmaid's Tale (Atwood)

    (Honorable mention: Messiah (Vidal))


    “After a while I realized I was doing what I had done before, creating the “third” - the woman altogether better than I was. For I could positively mark the point where Ella left reality, left how she would, in fact, behave because of her nature; and move into a large generosity of personality impossible to her. But I didn’t dislike this new person I was creating; I was thinking that quite possibly these marvelous, generous things we walk side by side with in our imaginations could come in existence, simply because we need them, because we imagine them. Then I began to laugh because of the distance between what I was imagining and what in fact I was, let alone what Ella was.”

    Could you and Strato explain this to me? I hate being so thick, but...there it is.


    The melting of Dresden, and the images my mind conjured up after his descriptions.
    I googled the book earlier, and had forgotten how the Tralfamadorians looked:
    'The extraterrestrial race who appear (to humans) like upright toilet plungers with a hand atop, in which is set a single, green eye.'
    Much like Quinn's description of Palin. ;-}


    I've been tempted to download 'The Golden Notebook' onto my kindle, but I'm afraid, based on your quoted text, that it might cut so close to the bone, it might facilitate my falling into despair while traveling alone in foreign lands, (something I'm completely capable of accomplishing without Lessing's help). Know any good comedies?


    Hey Ickyma -- I've overlooked Messiah, which is surprising since I really like Vidal. Thanks for the tip -- any synopsis or excerpts?


    Political comedies? Is that an oxymoron? Oh, maybe Palin's book and it's satiric other?
    I wish I could recall the name of the book I read last year by an American journalist living in London. Her chapters on speeches in Parliament and decision-making debate by MPs was so funny I could not finish my turn in reading it out loud with friends. It'll come back to me...


    I'll give you at teaser:

    Church of Death.
    :)


    Oxymoron? Hmm... I'm thinking redundant, maybe?


    I feel strangely compelled by the tale of Animal Farm in these times, in which a heroic groundswell of cries for "CHANGE" results in some fellow 4-legs-good Piggies taking over, the initial optimism and euphoria of the animal comrades slowly turning into acquiescence and acceptance of new hardships, commands and demands from the new Leader, not that different from those of yore, with new promises and laws morphing daily into incomprehensible mush and compromises, all animals being equal but some (eg. bankers) being more equal than others, new wars as the path to Peace, new TARP extracted from taxpayers as the path to economic salvation, the Workhorse, no longer bringing in bread, is asked to sacrifice its retirement, till at last, the animals peeked meekly through paneled glass to witness the sight of Pigs and Humans, Dems, Republicans, the MNCs, MIC and Wall St, all partying together in a long night orgy of inebriated gaiety on the Potomac, the whole hog, their reverie punctuated by the incessant bleating of "Four legs good, two legs bad!" from the sheep.


    As I interpreted Lessing's intent, her character Ella was an independent, self-sufficient career woman (a novelty in the post-WWII era) who gradually subsumed herself to a married man with whom she was having an affair. However, rather than succumbing to the temptation to rationalize and justify her own actions as "the other woman" by seeing his wife stereotypically as a harpy who did not understand him, she consciously focused on what she perceived as the inherent goodness of his wife -- a woman who was keeping the home fires burning, raising two children without the assistance of her betraying, absentee husband. And so, ironically, it was this admiration for a woman she had never met, but only imagined, that caused Ella to go against or beyond her own nature to become "more like her." Thus, though she retained her job, she gradually gave up her hard-won independence -- the quality that had attracted the man to begin with -- in an effort to be as "good" a person as his wife.
    I don't know that this character would fly fifty years later, as our culture would no longer automatically endorse the idea that passive endurance by a woman is her higher level of "good."
    But then again, maybe I'm having an outburst of irrational optimism.....


    Lawrence Block: The Burglar Who Traded Ted Williams

    David Seals: Sweet Medicine

    Fannie Flag's Whistlestop Cafe Book, I forget the name.


    Brilliant, Querty. Thanks. Animal Farm -- another must re-read.


    Sorry, this reply about Lessing's Ella intended for Wendy Davis.


    Spot on.


    Thank ya kindly, Ms. Staebler. How interesting, and it helps sort out the passage for me.
    Seems she also let go of the lies we can tell ourselves when our hormones and pheromones are in high gear, hmmm?


    Thank you wwstaebler and Ickyma. I shall be reading The Golden Notebook and Messiah when I get jaded again, i.e. in the very near future!


    Oooh, Atwood! I love her interviews: "Wanna bet??'


    I thought it might be about the vital imaginations
    we need to survive our circumstances and move forward.
    More "anything is possible" than bummer. Ha.


    Strato -- in my next life may I be wired as you are? Cup half full rather than half empty or, in your case as I perceived it, cup overflowing because you can imagine it being so.


    Cheers Staebler!

    Beknowen full
    of it or non
    The wisest wit I warn
    be ever torn.