The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age

    Paul Ryan runs home to Mommy

    Paul Ryan and his mother will be touring Florida this weekend and will be visiting the Villages, a large retirement center north of Orlando. I conjured such a Ryan trip to the Villages in a recent blog post here but admit that I completely mis-underestimated the potential leverage of Ryan bringing his mother along for the ride. In contrast to Romney, who shower-sang "America the Beautiful" at the Villages a few weeks ago, Ryan is likely to generate the best T.V. footage of the campaign there.

    No finer, insulated, Republican, Senior, Medicare recipient, controlled audience, tight restrictions venue could have been invented for Ryan than taking his Mom to the Villages. I can't wait to see just the two of them having lunch at a company-owned restaurant in a faux, Disney-like "town square". Perhaps in deference to his Mom the ever intrusive, prison-yard-like loud speakers will be silenced. Well, the Villagers would probably enjoy listening to Paul Ryan and his Mom rather than Fox News and Paul Harvey---at least on this one Saturday.

    Ryan needs a sure bet like a hoot n' anny at the Villages to balance out a weak performance atop the mixed-messaged national stage onto which Romney threw him---a week in which Mitt's flip flopping on the Ryan budget vs. the Romney budget was laughable stuff. Romney managed to step on Ryan's mix all week long---reinvigorating the tax return issue, using a silly and ultra-amateurish white board display to Perot-ize the Medicare debate---and worst of all, wasting two days in a hyperbolic response to the bait which Biden dangled in front of him. Romney was a counter melody and a complete distraction to the Ryan rollout. And doesn't the campaign hand book say that the Veep is supposed to attack the other side? But maybe Romney's campaign was providing cover for Ryan who wasn't really all that impressive either out on the stump or in T.V. interviews.

    After spending his adult life building a mythical narrative about his purist and intellectual qualifications, Ryan has found himself in a box and a compromised position. It took about one day for the Press to point out that Ryan was a player in the Bush spending spree. Then Ryan had to cover his tracks on his own $700 Billion "cuts" in Medicare with wonk-ish gibberish---"Obama did it first", or maybe it should be, "Mommy, don't blame me, Obama hit little Medicare first".

    Ryan's interview with Brit Hume was classic "hand in the cookie jar" material. Then yesterday in Cincinnati, Ryan fumbled his response to a question about seeking Stimulus money for his own district. Frankly, of all the possible attacks on Ryan's mythical purist character, the stimulus money request letters are the most cutting, in my opinion, because his two-faced ploy is black and white. He criticized Obama's stimulus, then admitted that it would create 7,600 jobs in his own district. Throwing his staff under the bus makes Ryan look all the more disingenuous. But there is always this:---"Mommy, my staff sent that letter, not me."

    Now my intent is not to discredit Ryan's mother. If my mother were still on this earth she would have done exactly the same thing Ryan's mother is doing---if I had asked her. But I'd like to think I would not have dragged my own mother out on such a blatant political ploy as pretending to preserve Medicare, a successful government program, when my underlying motive was to privatize the program for the benefit of the healthcare industry.  

    Apparently toting Mom along to defend Republican preservation of Medicare is the du jour advertising tactic for Republican candidates up and down the races. And such a tactic is likely to generate a certain amount of sympathy. But fissures in Ryan's resume are opening up on a daily basis, and I am not sure Mom can make those go away. 

    My cousin, Eddie, who lives in the Villages and most likely will be hootin' and hollerin' for Ryan, had a misogynistic joke back in high school which, mostly, he himself laughed at. "You know, Oxy, that girl has an hour glass figure---but the bottom half's missing." Har, Har. I don't suppose that joke goes over very well in a retirement setting, but I think there is a big part of Ryan's resume which has been missing. Looking beyond the phenomenal hordes of salivating-Senior-photo-ops in the Villages, there will be many more days to scrutinize Ryan when he comes back out on the school yard by himself.  

     

        

    Comments

    I promise my fellow Dagbloggers that this will be my last Paul Ryan post for at least a week. When I heard of Ryan's upcoming visit to the Villages on Saturday, I just couldn't resist it.


    NO NO Don't stop. laugh

    -That is all


    I second that emotion and urge you to continue (please).  cheeky


    O.k., then. "Paul Ryan......"


    i dont know which of ryans situatioins i like best  1) i was against the stimulus, before i covertly took the money, while i railed against the stimulus.  2) my tax returns needed a lil touch up, retroactively,  another failure to disclose to the IRS, sound familiar, romneyesque?  3) mommy, obama made me put the 700B takeaway from medicare, and it is his fault, he did it first! damn, this dude has some issues, and they are all of his own making. and, o yes: hey, girl, love your body, but i dont trust you with it. is that how to make smaller government?


    Thanks, Jacksmith. I really do wonder how his visit to the Villages played, down there, and on the national stage. Obviously I think his entire week was a process of reverse engineering his mythical purist resume, and, I want to believe that his general disingenuousness will rub off on his Medicare arguments. But I don't know, and have a concern that the linking of Medicare "cuts" to the dreaded Obamacare is cutting some ice with Seniors.

     


    so his mommy will be a real-live cardboard cut-out that stands there with a smile on her face and eyes wide open taking in the sights completely distracted while her son uses her image to trash medicare. and when he hits points and no reactions registers with her, the audiance will think what he's saying must be okay if his mommy doesn't react.


    Thanks, Beetle. That's the picture I was missing. Beautiful.


    First time reading your blog and I am not one to be condescending but its rather difficult not to be when responding to such obvious lack of logic or honest pursuit of truth. I can't figure out if you are so purely partisan that you have blinded yourself or if you are purely pandering to to fellow partisans (who seem to be weak minded or ignorant).  Ryan voted for the initial TARP funds and said that it was a "painful vote" but need to save an economy on the brink.  He voted against the second stimulus package and fought hard to defeat it.  Once passed he lobbied for funds for his state.  As if those who fought to keep the speed limit at 55 in the 90s should somehow never drive over 55 once the law changed.  Stimulus money once passed was "sunk cost" and cannot be recovered so should be used in the best possible ways.  Ryan never argued that they would not create jobs in the short run only that the long term debt (over 1 trillion owed to China) is bad for America's future.

    This is already too long so I won't point out the other exaggerations and inconsistencies in your writing.  I'm all for the expression of opinion and thanks for allowing me to express mine.

    Registered Independent


    Thanks, Truthhound, that was very civil. And you are certainly right about my partisans being weak minded or ignorant, anyone reading these pages would reach the same conclusion.

    I'll check out the two stimulus votes but my recollection was that they were not all that different---so the "no" vote might be considered by some as "grandstanding". My point is that he and the extreme Congress and their ilk have daily chanted that the stimulus didn'd create jobs and therefore Obama failed. If you don't see the hypocrisy in then turning around and saying the opposite, I can't help you.

    And please don't ask me for the specific reference where Ryan says that "Obama failed because the stimulus didn't create jobs" because I don't have it. But if you can prove he didn't say it I'll send Ryan a $50 donation as I'm already feeling guilty about bringing his Mom into all of this---except that he did it first.   

    There's a play on "55" but it's time for my nap.  


    Allegiance to the truth is certainly honorable. So if you're such  a non partisan seeker of truth I'm wondering  why you're so upset with  some random blogger who did not lie but simply posted a very partisan  take on Ryan's inconsistent behavior but you don't seem at all concerned that Ryan lied when asked about it. Its unfortunate you weren't there to advise him. Your rationalization for Ryan's inconsistent behavior would have been better than being caught in an outright lie.

    http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2012/08/presented-with-letters-ryan...

    After repeated denials, Paul Ryan has admitted he requested stimulus cash even after sharply criticizing the program.

    Ryan had denied doing so as recently as Wednesday, when he spoke to ABC’s Cincinnati affiliate, WCPO, in Ohio.

    “I never asked for stimulus,” Mitt Romney’s new running mate said. “I don’t recall… so I really can’t comment on it. I opposed the stimulus because it doesn’t work, it didn’t work.”

    Two years ago, during an interview on WBZ’s NewsRadio he was asked by a caller if he “accepted any money” into his district. Ryan said he did not.

    “I’m not one [of those] people who votes for something then writes to the government to ask them to send us money. I did not request any stimulus money,” the congressman answered.


    Thanks, Kat. Hadn't heard about the retraction. How was such a bold intellectual caught up in such a memory lapse?  Now we can move on to his extreme positions, on for example, Personhood.


    Oh yeah the fetal personhood bill. A fetus becomes a citizen at the moment of fertilization. Let's see how that works in other countries that have it.

    http://jezebel.com/5935734/the-pregnant-teen-cancer-patient-who-couldnt-...

    The pregnant Dominican teenager who had to wait twenty days to start receiving chemotherapy for her acute leukemia because of her country's draconian anti-abortion laws has died.

    The anonymous teen was 16 years old and only nine weeks pregnant when the controversy began. Her plight gained attention over the last few weeks as doctors debated whether it was morally correct to start treating her cancer, given as Article 37 of the Dominican Constitution states that "the right to life is inviolable from the moment of conception and until death." It took doctors and the Dominican government a full 20 days to decide that God and Country might care about the actually living mother's life, too, not just the fetus inside of her, and allow the treatment. By then, it was too late.


    Lovely. Had no knowledge of this law; now suspect that the culture of the country of origin of many of my neighbors is partly to blame for one of my nabe's major problems.


    When one surveys the complaints about unspent stimulus money in different states, the common cry is that the money will go away if not used as specified within a certain amount of time. That dilemma implies the very opposite of a "sunk cost" where the money has already been spent.


    Thanks, Moat. Very well put. But is Ryan a sunk cost?


    JFK brought his mother Rose EVERYWHERE on the campaign trail.

    Obama would have, had his mother lived. He talked about her not having health insurance when she was ill. We learned that was not quite true.


    Thanks. You may be right about JFK and President Obama. And I'm o.k. with comparing Ryan's Mom to Rose Kennedy, even though Rose perhaps would be in a separate category, having had two sons in combat fighting for the country's freedoms in WWII. Another difference might be that Rose and her son fought to keep our freedoms whereas Ryan and his ilk are attempting to remove freedoms, as in the attempt to block minorities and the elderly from voting through Voter ID laws. I don't know if Ryan's Mom is involved in charitable work trying to help the poor or prevent peoples freedoms from being trampled. If you have any information along that line please mention it.

    The real point of my piece was the duplicity of Ryan using his Mom as a prop in his underlying effort to end Medicare, a program from which his Mom is benefiting- --and turn the program over to a healthcare company. I suppose if you agree with Ryan's underlying agenda to destroy Medicare as a government program because you, like him, are philosophically opposed to government programs, even a good one with 3% administrative costs---then you would be more agreeable than I am with Ryan using his mother as a prop for such a purpose. And perhaps you, like the Ryans, are wealthy enough not to have to depend upon Medicare, or---don't know your age---will be able to afford the additional $6400 in costs through a voucher program with a private company. 

    Also, Ryan intends to end a large chunk of Medicaid which is used to care for old folks in nursing homes, but neither he nor his mother will mention nursing home care cuts during their visit to the Villages---pobably because with the Ryan's wealth, they've got nursing home care of $3000 per month factored into their investnment income.  

    Thanks for commenting, that's what makes the world go around. If my Mom were still around I would gladly be on stage with her although the purpose would probably be to highlight her wonderful art pieces and her many charitable acts towards others rather than to promote my own agenda of destroying the benefits of others for my own political gain.   

     


    There is an article about Ryan's visit to the Villages today in Daily Kos, "Paul Ryan hunts for votes in Republican utopia--or dystopia---".