The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    Ramona's picture

    After all that, I can still be shocked. That's shocking

    So this is what it’s come to.
    After four years of invective, four years during which the right has called President Obama a traitor, a communist, a fraud, an affirmative-action case, a terrorist-sympathizer, and a tyrant, its shrillest voices have been reduced to the most primal insult of all. They are calling Obama’s mother a whore.
    MichelleGoldberg, The Daily Beast, 9/28/12

    I'll get right to it:  After reading Goldberg's piece, my stomach is churning; it's telling me if I don't stop thinking about this, I may just vomit.  I'll admit when it comes to the really ugly stuff, if there's any chance I can avoid it I will.  I'm chicken that way.  But I can't ignore this, because the last thing I want is for vicious lies borne of pure hate to become trivial or normal.  We're dangerously close to that point already.

    There's nothing trivial or normal about mailing out millions (that's millions) of copies of "Dreams from my Father", an artlessly fabricated anti-Obama movie by a producer/director named Joel Gilbert.  The movie is narrated by an actor playing Barack Obama and depicts his mother, Stanley Ann Dunham, as a loose slut who lied about who Obama's father really was. (According to the film, he wasn't a Kenyan, but an American poet and black activist named Frank Marshall Davis, who had ties to Communist/Socialist movements in Chicago and Hawaii, and whose genes the Communist/Socialist Obama apparently inherited.)

    In the film, Obama's grandfather is supposed to have used his job as furniture salesman as a front for nefarious CIA duties.  Nude pictures, purportedly of Obama's mother (purportedly taken by Davis, who purportedly had a history of sending out nude pictures of women), grace the screen for long, lascivious seconds.  It leaves no scum-covered boulder unturned.

    If this were just some juvenile video, it might not be worth noting, but, as Goldberg says:

    What matters here is not that a lone crank made a vulgar conspiracy video, one that outdoes even birther propaganda in its lunacy and bad taste. It’s that the video is finding an audience on the right. Gilbert claims that more than a million copies of Dreams From My Real Father have been mailed to voters in Ohio, as well between 80,000 and 100,000 to voters in Nevada and 100,000 to voters in New Hampshire. “We’re putting plans in place, as of next week, to send out another 2 [million] or 3 million, just state by state,” he told me.

     While Goldberg admits she can't verify those numbers, she's finding evidence of some active distribution: 

    But the fact is, people are reporting receiving the disc in the mail. Tea Party groups and conservative churches are screening it. It was shown at a right-wing film festival in Tampa during the Republican National Convention, and by Phyllis Schlafly’s Eagle Forum Council in Missouri. Alabama GOP Chairman Bill Armistead recently recommended it during a speech, saying, “I’ve seen it. I verified that it is factual, all of it. People can determine.”

     In this year's campaign, the Republicans have found themselves with nothing to work with. They boxed themselves into a corner by going along with Mitch McConnell's promise to do whatever it takes to keep Obama from earning a second term.  Any good they might have done for the people they'd hurt over the previous eight years would have required Obama's signature as the final step.  It would have looked like they were working for him.  Or at least with him.  They couldn't do it.  So they did nothing,

    So when this kind of thing happens they don't take steps to denounce it.  If anything, they encourage it.  It builds their case without their having to do a thing.

    When Goldberg says, "They are calling Obama's mother a whore," unfortunately she isn't just talking about Gilbert's movie.  In this piece she talks also about Dinesh D'Souza's equally odious and deceitful book, Obama's America: Unmaking the American Dream. (The follow-up to last year's whopper, The Roots of Obama's Rage and companion to his widely panned movie, 2016, Obama's America.)

    The right wing loves D'Souza's seeming intellectual offerings, happily overlooking how riddled they are with provable lies:

    Obama is not merely the presiding instrument of American decline, he is the architect of American decline. He wants America to be downsized. He wants Americans to consume less, and he would like to see our standard of living decline relative to that of other nations. He seeks a diminished footprint for America in the world. He detests America's traditional allies, like Britain and Israel, and seeks to weaken them; he is not very worried about radical Muslims acquiring a nuclear bomb or coming to power in countries like Tunisia and Egypt. He is quite willing to saddle future dollars toward this end and if he had been permitted, he would have spent trillions more. He has shown no inclination, and has no desire, to protect America's position as number one in the world; he would be content to see America as number 18, or number 67, just another country seated at the great dining table of nations.

    When Mitt Romney was caught saying what he said about the 47% who make up Obama voters--that all 47% of us are lazy moochers who just want government handouts, so who needs us, anyway?--I thought that would be the end of it for Mitt.  It wasn't.

    When Mitt assured 60 Minute's Scott Pelley that every American already has health care--it's called Their Nearest Emergency Room--and when Joe Scarborough dissolved into infantile blubbering on set after watching the clip the next morning, I thought maybe this was it; Mitt was cooked.  He wasn't. Not completely, anyway.

    Even earlier, when Mitt chose as his running mate, Paul Ryan, a slavishly anti-social program guy even during what everybody agrees is a relentlessly tenacious depression/recession, it should have been a call to quit these guys.  It wasn't.

    Plain old citizen Grover Norquist's success at exacting a mandatory anti-tax pledge from every Republican politician should have sent shuddery danger signals to the voting public.  It didn't.

    Paul Ryan's OldTestamenty attacks on women, condemning both birth control and abortion, should have eliminated him from any chance at the vice presidency.  It didn't.

    The rise of ALEC and the revelations of the Koch brothers' relentless support and financing of anti-government members of congress, along with anti-democratic governors, red flags should have been waving frantically.  So far only half the country is seeing them.

    With all that, I thought I might be shock-proof by now.  Turns out I'm not.

    (Cross-posted at Ramona's Voices)

    Topics: 

    Comments

    So the Ivana DeSeevya account that it all started when Grandpa brought back a frozen test tube baby from a secret Third Reich biological weapons lab, in a failed Nazi scheme to clone Adolf Hitler, isn't true?


    Ramona,

    Yes, this is truly horrific and disgusting and all things sick and wrong, but.....

    These people put forth this type of crap because they can.  They are the equivalent of a really nasty bully brigade that revels in the destruction and chaos they create. 

    But, few, if any, call them out.  For example:

    Alabama GOP Chairman Bill Armistead recently recommended it during a speech, saying, “I’ve seen it. I verified that it is factual, all of it. People can determine.”

    If I were the Dems I would tell Billy Boy to show me the documents, reveal the sources that verified it is factual. 

    I'd keep hammering away, file a lawsuit and keep it up until these vermin were begging for mercy, issued a retraction and didn't have any assets left.  Because, the truth is until there are harsh consequences they will just keep goin' on and it will just get worse.

    Bully Brigades like this are the direct result of no one standing up and speaking out.  You don't 'let them' continue on the path of destruction.


    It is because they suck. They can't do anything but attack a woman who is dead, and they are only doing that because she has mixed race children. They should be shunned, too bad they won't be, and that is part of the reason Republicans appear to be Neanderthals. Oh wait, that is mean to Neanderthals isn't it.


    You know what line this all boils down to?

    AND SO'S YER MOTHER!

    hahahahahaha

    These are terrible people.

    They take a war hero like Kerry and turn him into some...some what?

    I still do not understand what they were doing with Kerry and why his peeps could not straighten that lie/line up in 2004.

    To take the time and money and effort to eviscerate? this poor woman who died young is just beyond me but they attempted the same shameful time, money and effort to do the same against Clinton!

    The fact is that Romney The Elder had been brainwashed concerning the Vietnam War, just as all Americans had been.

    Just as Kerry had been brainwashed concerning the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan; so had the American People.

    Thank the Good Lord Barry is used to all this. Barry has lived with this kind of propaganda all his life and he is COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!

    Sticks and stones and Roves and and Arpaios and Trumps and all the rest of them have no effect whatsoever on this Great President.

    And I aint worried!

     

     


    I love conspiracy stuff--and have wasted most of a perfectly good day checking this one out. I probably would have spent my time better by researching who REALLY funded the anti-muslim documentary, which goes to show you how pathetic this story is.

    Here are my findings. (Cue mysterious music.)

    It is highly unlikely that the woman in the photos is Ann Dunham. Not impossible, because the whole point of conspiracy theories is that there's ALWAYS A CHANCE!!!!!!!!! But let's be honest here--the young Ann Dunham was a fresh-looking person, and in many ways all young people are lovely. But by model standards, Obama's mom had a face like a torn combat boot, eyes that sloped downward, and a jaw longer than a drive to the southern border of Mexico. On top of that, I have yet to see a photo in which she looked comfortable or natural.

    The woman in the photos is...pretty. In addition, she looks comfortable having her picture taken, not only in the nude but in exotic gear. Not many people can both look and be that comfortable in front of a camera. It's one of the reasons that not many people are models. It's one of the reasons that Norma Jean Baker's fate was sealed the moment she first stepped in front of a lens. Models look like models--even the ones who never get famous--they just look better and more natural in front of a camera than the rest of us do.

    Now, it's POSSIBLE that Dunham had the world's greatest makeup artist for this shoot, and that what's-his-face was such a fantastic photographer that he captured Dunham's single moment of inner vixenhood, a quality that vanished after the film shoot and never appeared again. But if he were that good, he'd have been working more. And so, probably, would she.

    It seems mean to exonerate Dunham here based on the idea that she didn't really have model ju-ju, but there it is. Obama inherited her face shape and eye-slope, and it looks better on him than it did on her.

    It appears that the model in the photos may have been a woman named Marcy Moore.

    What I'm interested in here is who is paying to send copies of this movie around the country. I didn't see a producer listed, so I'm assuming it's self-produced or the producer did not wish to be named. (And it wouldn't have cost much to make so it's very possible that Gilbert just threw it together over a few weeks with an editor and a few voice actors.) MVD, the distribution company? Would they underwrite the costs? I'm pretty sure Joel Gilbert has made pretty good money from his previous rather wacky film efforts and could have done this himself, but this one seems like a bigger fish to fry, especially since there's a reasonable chance that he's about to have his ass sued.

    Curious.


    Great work, Erica (and Peracles, too).  I haven't looked at the pictures and probably won't so I'll take your word for the differences in the features.  I wonder, too, who is paying for this?  And I wonder which churches are so filled with Obama hate they would actually buy this film to show to their congregations?

    But as nauseated as it makes me, I'm also fascinated by the details.  So thanks for working so hard on this.  Much to think about. 

    I'm sure the truth is out there; now it's up to you two sleuths to find it!


    Marcy Moore was a porn star who looks a tad bit like Ann Dunham, except very different breast size and Ann quite a bit homelier. It's true Obama looks a lot like Davis when posed the same way as they're both by no coincidence black - though different lips, chins.... Though to be fair, maybe headshape closer fit than Barack Sr? (Barack has his grandfather's ears for sure, and also similar headshape, though I think his father is proven not black, but anything goes these days). They also managed to assume Davis slept with Ann Dunham at 13 because he said he slept with a 13-year-old named Ann, even though that was with his first wife 20-30 years before, and Ann didn't show up in Hawaii until 17. It's all pretty bizarrely comical, and there's a good deal of dissonance among those who can't give up the bigamist Kenyan Marxist to have the black pervert poet Marxist. So they scream Obama's not eligible to be president (misreading the Constitution and going on the Kenyan father) while showing how he's a member of Spartanist Youth League and a tool of the Kremlin based on the other candidate, while somehow fitting CIA granddad into the destroyer of worlds category as well.

    [wrote this up but didn't post for a few hours - Erica filled in details meantime]


    Before the election in 2008 I recall another video being mailed out by the millions. It was some kind of anti-Muslim propaganda warning that if Obama was elected, we'd all be dead in a week or some such cataclysmic event. I cannot recall the title, but I do remember getting a copy of the damn thing. I didn't even open it. Just busted it up and threw it in the trash.

    I wish I could remember the title.


    This isn't about Obama. It's just politics. When we stopped McCain in South Carolina in 1999 by letting it be known that he had a black child, he got all upset at me. I had to remind him that it was just politics. Don't take it too serious. :)   (when I do that thing it means a smiley face).

    --W


    As ugly as it gets the good news is that somehow with all of that disgusting slime being spewed much of it is not going to 'stick'.

     

    As far as being shocked goes.  This morning I am shocked after watching 'The Colbert Report' of all sourced... to find out that there is a company that sells the 'products' created by U.S prison labor where of course they live 'in prison' and under those conditions and are paid 'slave wages'. Apparently this company was allowed to sell these products to federal agencies only but now that is changingn and American manufacturers and their employees will not have to compete for their business and jobs with slave labor in the U.S..

    How can this be happening?

     


    Duplicate removed.