Orion's picture

    Twin Burdens: Child Care Costs and Living in Seattle

    Hello all!

    Instead of speaking about recent tragedies and an increasing chance of a third world war, I decided to direct you guys toward some local issues. This was originally slated for a local magazine which did not answer my inquiries.

    “Family values” is spoken of often in politics. It usually alludes to incredibly superficial issues – same sex marriage or abortion being among them. The actual politics of raising a family in this society are not mentioned often.

    It’s incredibly expensive to raise a child in this country. Daniel Marans, a reporter for the Huffington Post, said that, in many states, it is actually “more expensive than college.” More specifically, the cost of child care for one infant exceeded that of the cost of in state tuition at a public four year university.

    I talked to Christina Jacobson, who recently graduated with her Bachelor’s degree from Western Governor’s University, a Utah based accredited university that allows people to complete their degrees online. Jacobson lives in Seattle’s Capitol Hill neighborhood, where Capitol Hill Times reported the average rent cost in 2014 as $1728. She grapples with that financial environment while mothering two children. She has naturally reached out to the state to help with her situation and has found the system all too flawed.

    “It’s just a super flawed system,” she said, “and the state doesn’t help as many people as they should. I once got kicked off of state assistance for day care because I made $26 over the allowable income limit. So because I went over, I was on the hook for 1000/month for care which would’ve made it so I couldn’t afford rent or food. I had to agree to work less hours in order to keep my assistance. It’s like you can’t win.”

    Looking at numbers specifically, programs like Bright Horizons in Redmond rake in infant care costs of $2,200 a month while Kidspace in Ballard charges $2,150 per month and the Seattle Infant Development Center and Preschool in Seattle’s central areas charges $2,000 a month. Those statistics are courtesy of Caley Cook, writing for the news magazine Cross Cut.

    As unaffordable as that may seem, costs are far, far more extreme in other parts of the country. In the Bay Area, more specifically San Francisco County, the average cost for an infant in a child care center was $13,370. In Alameda County, meanwhile, the cost of an infant in a child care center was $13,320.

    Such conditions, not conducive to any conception of childcare, help explain why an avowed socialist like Kshama Sawant not only won election to city council but also re-election. Socialist politics is on ascent nationally, and Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders has targeted America’s child care system, which he criticizes as an “embarrassment,” citing the pay rate by which childcare workers are paid as one of the most emblematic symptoms of the problem.

    “To allow childcare workers, people who work with these little kids, to be making McDonald’s type wages is an embarrassment. We need the best trained, best paid, most qualified people to be working with these young kids.” What he describes as “quality affordable health care” is a major element of his presidential campaign, specifically an “early child care program” which would promote “children’s social, emotional and physical development critical to their futures and the future of our nation.”

    As of this writing, Sanders had made quite an impact on the national stage, pulling Hillary Clinton to the left of many issues. Clinton still remains the top contender by large double digits in her poll numbers. National policy on child care has the potential still to lurch to the left but not to the extent that a President Sanders would propel it.

    Progress is nevertheless being made. Propositon 1A, which passed in Seattle’s last general election, guaranteed Seattle’s exceptionally high minimum wage of $15 expansion toward childcare workers while reducing overall child care costs to only 10% of overall family income.

    There’s still a long way to go but steadily, conditions in Washington state may become amenable to family rearing. Hopefully the rest of the country will follow suit.

    Comments

    Great post.  Kinder care is important and the government should be providing it.  They do this in many countries. 


    Thanks Orion.  This is spot-on.  I would also note that it is also a national embarrassment that we allow McDonald's to pay its hard-working employees so little while it reaps enormous profits and the best solution is various forms of free government-provided childcare available for parents of all pre-teens.
     


    Nice reporting here, Michael.

    We have decided on a system that values work but, ironically, taxe work at much higher rates than it does investments.  We have a system that offers assistance, but only in limited circumstances and that is bounded by bureaucratic rules so that $26 dollars can be a dividing line between help and no help.

    If science is supposed to better our lot in life and economics is a science, then the point of economics should be to eradicate poverty and want.  Yet, so often, we our talk about economics simply justifies poverty.

    I'd say that this is a far larger issue than ISIS, by the way.


    I'm glad that you guys enjoyed this. The parenting magazine I sent it to didn't respond to my inquiries. These are very good numbers though - it looks like there was an audience.


    Latest Comments