The Bishop and the Butterfly: Murder, Politics, and the End of the Jazz Age
    Richard Day's picture

    TAMING THE GREAT VAMPIRE SQUID

    Matt Taibbi Matt Taibbi.jpg

    Mr. Madoff, who is serving a 150-year sentence, seemed frail and a bit agitated compared with the stoic calm he maintained before his incarceration in 2009, perhaps burdened by sadness over the suicide of his son Mark in December…

     “They had to know,” Mr. Madoff said. “But the attitude was sort of, ‘If you’re doing something wrong, we don’t want to know.’ ”

    While he acknowledged his guilt in the interview and said nothing could excuse his crimes, he focused his comments laserlike on the big investors and giant institutions he dealt with, not on the financial pain he caused thousands of his more modest investors. In an e-mail written on Jan. 13, he observed that many long-term clients made more in legitimate profits from him in the years before the fraud than they could have elsewhere. “I would have loved for them to not lose anything, but that was a risk they were well aware of by investing in the market,” he wrote.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/16/business/madoff-prison-interview.html?_r=1

    Matt Taibbi is back at it again. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/why-isnt-wall-street-in-jail-20110216

     

    C covers most of the article right here: http://dagblog.com/reader-blogs/how-wall-street-beat-rap-9133

    WHY ISN’T WALL STREET IN JAIL? Taibbi asks.

    Well, I could posit a number of rhetorical questions.

    I mean why is Rummy allowed to write a tome full of lies and preach about the coming caliphate?

    Why does Dicky Cheney run free as the Tin Man seeking a heart and preaching foreign policy.

    And why does Gonzo and Bolton and Bybee and Feith and a host of other war criminals escape even a deposition inquiring into their past felonies?

    So Matt publishes another ten page essay that rocks and this time it concerns Wall Street.

    Generally speaking, there is nothing new here.

    The people who run our economy are selfish felons who lie, cheat and steal their way through each and every day. They cheat the government, they cheat their shareholders…hell, they cheat each other.

    And rarely, oh so rarely, someone is thrown under the bus and ends up in prison for a couple of years.

    It is the specifics that Taibbi is good at. He speaks with the right people.

    In other words, he finds those who have been screwed over by the powers that be and they cannot wait to speak with him.

    Why the people at the DOJ cannot figure out this stratagem is beyond me.

    Just find people who were fired for doing the right thing; find people who are holding grudges against the powerful. Then speak with them.

    They are willing to tell their stories.

    They are wanting to tell their stories.

    They are waiting to tell their stories.

    As Matt puts it:

    Just ask the people who tried to do the right thing. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/why-isnt-wall-street-in-jail-20110216

    Most of them, of course, already told their stories. They prepared long memos sending them to SEC headquarters; sending them to DOJ contacts; sending them to the FBI.

    Taibbi gives examples where the DOJ ‘had the goods’ and sat on the case for a year or longer.

    And everybody knows that evidence disintegrates over time; like picked vegetables dissolving into putrid masses in some abandoned pantry. Witnesses move or even die. Bank accounts are erased as well as hard drives. Coconspirators get their stories ‘straight’.

    And of course top students graduate from top universities, arrive at the SEC and find themselves making millions a few years later with the firms they were appointed to oversee.

    Good to have you here Thomkins, I think you are going to like it around here.

    Thanks Mr. Andrews. Oh and by the way a corner office would be just fine and dandy.

    A corner office? I am not sure I quite understand….

    Well there was the matter of the IPO where your company pocketed one hundred mill with you personally seeing ten points on that and then it all went up in one big puff of smoke and…..

    A CORNER OFFICE IT IS. They told me you were good Thomkins, but Jesus…

    These folks actually take pride in what they do. And getting away with it just increases their adrenaline high.

    I mean Johnnie is pinched for mixing up the medicine in the basement and serves ten years in some private prison providing slave labor to some corporation that makes money off of him and the taxpayer.

    And ABC corporation processes the numbers and figures that it can take a hit in the form of a fine for a hundred million because it made one billion from the scam that formed the basis for the indictment.

    AND NOBODY FROM ABC CORPORATION ENDS UP IN JAIL.

    If you are a resident of some godforsaken village in Afghanistan, you have witnessed murder and mayhem for decades. Death and disease become common place and it turns some humans into  rather thick skinned personages without much humanity.

    We can read articles on Wall Street graft every single day if we wish. If you look for them hard enough they abound and have abounded for decades.

    This graft has become so common place that the electorate just does not give a damn anymore.

    Things do not have to be like this.

    There are very few money making ventures that involve government.

    We used to survive on tariffs and land. These two resources were all the Founding Fathers could rely on to keep the government afloat.

    Nowadays we give away our land to rich crooks who end up paying no taxes on its bounty.

    We give away our oil to companies like Exxon; and we not only do not tax Exxon, we give them hundreds of millions of dollars in order to help them steal our oil.

    But the SEC and the DOJ could be real money makers.

    If the staffs of these two agencies were increased a hundred fold, money would be pouring into our governmental coffers. Hundreds of billions of dollars in fines could be filling our governmental coffers even if we seem to have problems collecting taxes from these pricks.

    Find the culprits and indict them and convict them and repossess all of their properties.

    Sentence them to twenty years at hard labor. After five years of incarceration give them an early out with the institution of 10,000 hours of community service.

    None of this will ever happen of course.

    Taibbi concludes:

    The mental stumbling block, for most Americans, is that financial crimes don't feel real; you don't see the culprits waving guns in liquor stores or dragging coeds into bushes. But these frauds are worse than common robberies. They're crimes of intellectual choice, made by people who are already rich and who have every conceivable social advantage, acting on a simple, cynical calculation: Let's steal whatever we can, then dare the victims to find the juice to reclaim their money through a captive bureaucracy. They're attacking the very definition of property — which, after all, depends in part on a legal system that defends everyone's claims of ownership equally. When that definition becomes tenuous or conditional — when the state simply gives up on the notion of justice — this whole American Dream thing recedes even further from reality   http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/why-isnt-wall-street-in-jail-20110216?page=6

    Comments

     

    "And everybody knows that evidence disintegrates over time; like picked vegetables dissolving into putrid masses in some abandoned pantry."

    Wonderful image.  Please award yourself the line of the day for this.  

    P.S.  Is there a coming caliphate of calimari? 


    Well thanks Smith!

    I picture beckerhead picking up 1000 Arabian Nights by accident and figuring he had hit upon something!


    Richard, on the SEC and Madoff, Harry Markopolos was a the hedge fund trader who turned in Madoff 3-4 times over 10 years to 5 or more different offices or people in the SEC which only led to one incompetent SEC investigation around 2005 that cleared Madoff and his fund. Markopolos feared for his life as he tried to get Madoff investigated, because he knew Madoff controlled billions and that Madoff also handled money for some folks who may have been mob related, and that if caught, Madoff would go to jail for life so adding a murder charge would be no big deal if Madoff was ever brought to justice.

    Markopolos, in his book, No One Would Listen, leaves no doubt the big boys on The Street knew Madoff was not up and up, but in the words of Markopolos, everyone on Wall Street skirts the edge of legality all the time so they don't throw stones from their glass houses. The book is excellent and a page turner, it is available at most public libraries. Markopolos said he found 10 'funds of funds' in Europe (hedge funds which just put money in other hedge funds) that all thought they were the only Madoff client in Europe. A head of one of those European fund of funds who invested money from France, committed suicide in 2008, R. Thierry Magon de la Villehuchet.

    Markopolos worked for a fund that gave him the goal to match Madoff's fund results, which is why he got onto the Madoff thing to start with. He said the one tipoff was that Madoff in his fund reports said Madoff's option trades were orders of magnitude more than all options actually recorded for a given day in the market.

    Markopolos also gave extensive testimony about the SEC before Congress when they investigated Madoff, and Markopolos pulled no punches. His general line is the SEC is primarily there to protect Wall Street from the public, and the staff of the SEC is heavy on lawyers, not accountants, and that they 'couldn't find first base' if the entire staff was put into Fenway Park. He also mentions how the SEC employees all hope to get a job on Wall Street for what, as Gov. Walker of Wisconsin says, 'real money'.

    Markopolos testimony is at C-Span at link. Transcript of the testimony at link. It is definitely worth listening to this guy. Whether the SEC or the DOJ is any better at uncovering wrongdoing on Wall Street now than it has been historically is unknown to me.

    In Markopolos C-SPAN testimony it is mentioned that the SEC under Bush had a hotline for Wall Streeters to call at the SEC to stop or slow an investigation, but no phone number to call to initiate one.


    Well I shall look for the book NCD, for sure.

    If Martha Stewart were such a slam dunk for insider trading and all she did was get a tip from her stock broker (by the way what are stock brokers for anyway?), it could not be that hard to round up about a thousand traders tomorrow.


    Martha made several mistakes:

    1. She talked to the FBI (her beef wasn't insider trading, but "misleading" the feds)

    2. Too pretty, too smart, too unwilling to put out for slobs.(If you don't think there was a crucial moment in the fbi interview where the judicious application of lips to dick wouldn't have made everything right,  you don't know your "special agents"


    At the ivy leagues whilst on your way to your MBA you probably have at least a full semester on how to address the Feds!!


    Not exactly.  I'm an ABD, not an MBA.   Which means I am a trifle late on my dissertation.

    See, I got a Woodrow Wilson Fellowship in 1967 which included a stipend to take a year off and write my dissertation on Gouverneur Morris (who actually wrote the constitution, that is took home the report of the committee of the whole and rearranged (and changed a taste) it.

    But, Noooo. Rogie also had a job offer from Hunter College, which had gone over from being a all girls school two years before, so had only the hint of any male students.

    So I declined the stipend and took on 16 hours of teaching per week for 36 weeks or so.

    Which is way over my rated gainful employment output.

    Which crowded out the dissertation.


    ;ABD being shorthand for PhD, all but dissertation.

    It's so common they make an abbreviation for it.

    But to return to talking to the Feds, I recount a true story.

    I was visiting my parents, the phone rings, I'm alone.

    Me:Hello?

    Phone:Is Mr. (fill in my last name) There?

    Me: No . Can I take a message?

    Phone: Tell  him Jimmy Hoffa called.

    My father once paid 5 large in sanctions not to be put under oath.

    So I try to adhere to the principle that the default position is say nothing.


    Ah, you may have already said too much, Roger. You're talking Jimmy Senior, right?


     Of course.


     said too much

    No, if I said he used to fly back and forth to Arizona to advise Joe Bonnano during his protracted kidnapping that prevented him from ever responding to grand jury subpoenas from the New York U.S. Attorney's office, that would be too much.


    Right, that would have been way too much. So glad you didn't say that.


    For a split second after reading the title immediately followed by the photo, I thought the vampire squid to be tamed was Matt Taibbi.  SIgh.  

    Sometimes it seems like the most celebrated in-depth reporting serves as nothing more than chaff to draw attention away from what should be the true target.   

    In this case, the fundamental problem is a financial system with perverse incentives.  Imposing more or newer regulations; fining companies; or metaphorically lynching people will not change that.   Those may deter the suspect activiites until other people find another way or place to do the same thing all over again.   What good does that do in the long run?


    Oh the vampire squid metaphor was created by Taibbi in an early essay. It is kind of a well known line among muckrakers.

    Yeah, the system sucks.

    But that does not mean that the US could not collect an extra trillion dollars from the guys who control the damn system within a few years.

    Fear would not be a bad emotion to work with in that stratsophere of corruption.


    "What good does that do in the long run?"

    The same could be said for everything in life.  In the long run we are all dead. I for one would like my game of life to have some sense of justice.  

    At the absolute very least Joseph Cassano should be in jail.  In my world you don't bring down the world economy without some consquences (of course I would like many more to be in jail too).

    Nice to see you going strong DDay!


    Hey Saladin, good to see you!!!


    That French Guy just took a three year fall.

    And he only made off with seven-tenths of a billion   (Disclaimer-The bank claims losses around 5 billion euros)   That's a rounding error for Cassano.


    OK, Ok, I could be his mother, but I am totally attracted to Matt!


    hahaha

    Truth is ageless. ha